Kitabı oxu: «Neuralgia and the Diseases that Resemble it»
PREFACE
I believe it will not be disputed that there was considerable need for an English treatise dealing rather fully with the subject of Neuralgia, and therefore I hope that the profession will be willing to give me a hearing. The present work, moreover, does not profess to be a mere compilation of standard authorities corrected down to the present time, but puts forward a substantially new view of the subject – at least, a view that has been only briefly sketched by me in an article that appeared, three years ago, in Reynolds's "System of Medicine." My principal object, in writing this volume, was to vindicate for Neuralgia that distinct and independent position which I have long been convinced it really holds, and to prove that it is not a mere offshoot of the Gouty or Rheumatic diatheses, still less a mere chance symptom of a score of different and incongruous diseases. In order to set the diagnosis of true Neuralgia from its counterfeits in the clearest light, it seemed advisable to draw separate pictures of each of the latter (at least of as many as are of real importance) and present them separately, as a kind of gallery of spurious neuralgias, and this I have done in the second part of the volume. No one who had not tried to do it would imagine how difficult this latter kind of work is. It was necessary for the sketches to be very brief (unless my book was to become unmanageably large), and yet to be as truthfully characteristic as possible; and it was necessary also that only those diseases which so much resemble Neuralgia as practically to lead medical men astray in diagnosis, should be dealt with. The selection of the subjects, and the execution of this part, took a long time, though it only covers about fifty pages. Then, as regards Neuralgia itself, it became necessary to completely recast the chapters on "Pathology" and on "Complications," on account of some of the polite criticisms which Dr. Eulenburg directed (in his recent "Lehrbuch der Nervenkrankheiten") to my argument in the article above referred to, since it was obvious that a too brief statement of my views had caused them to be partially misunderstood by the German physician. These chapters (Part I., Chapters II. and III.) are certainly the most important portion of my book, and I would particularly direct attention to them, in order that their contents may be affirmed or corrected: the reader will at any time find that they contain a kind of investigation never before systematically carried out with regard to Neuralgia. The causes above mentioned, together with others over which I had no control, have kept back the appearance of this work so long beyond the date for which it was originally announced, that I feel I ought to apologize for an amount of delay that would seem hardly justified by the moderate size of the volume.
16 Wimpole Street, London, October 1, 1871.
INTRODUCTION.
ON PAIN IN GENERAL
Although it is, in a general way, unadvisable to introduce abstract discussions into a treatise which should be strictly practical, it is almost impossible to avoid some few general reflections on the physiological import of Pain, as a preliminary to the discussion of the maladies which form the subject of this volume. This whole group of disorders is linked together by the fact that pain is their most prominent feature; and, with regard to most of them, the relief of the pain is the one thing required of the physician. It seems, therefore, very important that we should ascertain, at least approximately, in what the immediate state consists, which consciousness interprets as pain. It is not necessary to enter at this stage into any inquiry as to the pathological causes of the phenomenon; what we know of these, and it is unfortunately too little, will be discussed in detail under the headings of the several affections which I shall have to describe.
The question before us now is this: What is that functional state of the nerves which consciousness interprets as pain? Is it, or is it not, an exaltation of the ordinary function of sensation?
The latter question is generally answered affirmatively, without much thought, by those to whom it casually occurs; but indeed there is plenty of prescriptive authority for so dealing with it. Pain has been described by some of the most distinguished writers on nervous diseases as a hyperæsthesia. Yet there is really little difficulty in convincing ourselves, if we institute a thorough inquiry into the matter, that pain is certainly not a hyperæsthesia, or excess of ordinary sensory function, but something which, if not the exact opposite of this, is very nearly so.
The leading fallacy in the common view is the confusion which is perpetually being made between function and action. Now, the function of individual nerves is very nearly a constant quantity, at least, it varies only within narrow limits; while the action of the same nerves may be almost any thing. The function of the nerve is that kind of work for which it is fit when its molecular structure is healthy; it is the series of dynamic reactions which are necessarily produced in nerve-tissue by the external influences which surround and impinge upon it in the conditions of ordinary existence. The action of nerves, under the pressure of extraordinary influences, may include all manner of vagaries which really have nothing in common with the effects of ordinary functional stimulation; which are, in fact, nothing but perturbation. No one can suppose, for instance, that the explosive disturbances of nerve-force which give rise to the convulsions of tetanus are any mere exaggerated degree of the orderly and symmetrical action by which the healthy nerve responds to the stimulus of volition ordering a given set of muscles to contract; they are something quite different in kind. And so it is with the sensory nerves. The functions of these conductors, in health, is to convey to the perceptive centres the sensations, varying only within a most limited range, which correspond to a state of well-being of the organs, and which excite only those reflex actions that are necessary to life. Thus the large surface of sensitive nerve terminals which is represented by the collective peripheral branches of the fifth cranial conveys to the medulla oblongata an impression, derived from the temperature and movement of the surrounding air, when the latter is neither too hot nor too cold, which imparts to the brain a perception of comfortable sensations, and excites in return the reflex action of breathing, which is necessary to life. But the impression produced on this same peripheral expanse of nerve-branches by prolonged exposure to cold wind may, and often does, convey to the centres sensations which are quite different and provokes reflex movements which are altogether abnormal. Pain is the product in one direction; sneezing, perhaps, in the other. It seems absurd to say that sneezing is any part of the function of those motor nerves whose action regulates the performance of expiration. And it appears to me not less absurd to say that pain is the function of the sensitive fibres of the trigeminus. But the best way, perhaps, to illustrate the looseness and incorrectness of applying the term "hyperæsthesia" (implying exalted function) to the state of sensitive nerves when suffering pain, is to examine the condition of distinctive perception in the very same parts to which the painful nerves are distributed. It will invariably be found, as we shall have occasion to see more fully proved hereafter, that, in parts which are acutely painful, a marked bluntness of the tactile perceptions can be detected. The tactile perceptions are, no doubt, conveyed by an independent set of fibres from those which convey the sense of pain.1 Yet it is surely impossible to believe the effect of the same influence, in functional power can be different – much more than it can be exactly opposite – in the two cases.
If pain be not a heightening of ordinary sensation, then we seem to be shut up to the idea that it is a perversion owing to a molecular change of some part of the machinery of sensation which frustrates function. For it is to be observed that, while the sensations conveyed by the healthy nerve are correct in the indications which they afford to the percipient brain, the indications given by pain are vague and untrustworthy, and often seriously misleading. Not to speak of the nerves of special sense, or of the fibres which convey the sensations of muscular movement, even the nerves of common sensation do carry to the internal perception, in health, a distinct impression of the well-being of the organs to which they are distributed. Mr. Bain2 has well pointed out the positive character of this feeling, which is so often incorrectly referred to as if it were a mere negation of feeling. It is a sensation of equable and diffused comfort, if I may be allowed to use the expression, which streams in from all parts of the organism; and there is no possibility of comparing it, in any scale of less or more, with the sensation of pain; for the latter commonly conveys no correct information as to the organ from which it proceeds, or appears to proceed. Especially is this the case in the neuralgias, for more commonly than not the apparent seat of the pain is widely removed from the actual seat of the mischief which causes it.
If we inquire a little further into the circumstances under which various kinds of pain occur, we gain some fresh suggestions. Among the neuralgias, those are the most acutely agonizing which occur under circumstances of impaired nutrition incident to the period of bodily decay, and strong reasons will be hereafter adduced for the belief that there is especial impairment of the nutrition of the central end of the painful nerves. To find a parallel to the severity of this kind of pains we must turn to the case of organic tumors, which, from their position, structure, and mode of growth, necessarily exercise continuous and severe pressure on the branches or the trunk of a nerve; or to the class of pains which attend severe cramp, or tonic contraction of muscles. Now, it can scarcely be doubted that in the latter instance there is an abnormally rapid and violent destruction of tissue going on; at the very least there is an extraordinarily violent and irregular manifestation of motor force. In any case the patent fact here is dynamic perturbation of a severe kind; and, in the instance of organic tumors exercising steady and continuously increasing pressure on nerves, one can scarcely doubt that a similar perturbation, less intense but more enduring, is necessarily set up. That which can be done in the way of producing severe pain by these severe affections of the peripheral portions of nerves, or of tissues lying outside them, we might a priori expect would be effected by slighter but continuous changes in the nutrition of the more important portion of the nerve itself – its central gray nucleus. One would say that a pathological process which continuously and progressively lowered the standard of nutrition here must interfere from hour to hour, certainly from day to day, with that regular and equable distribution of force which is the essence of unimpeded function.
Take, again, the case of the very severe pain which frequently attends inflammation of the pleura and of the peritoneum. Whatever theory of the causation of these pains we may adopt, it is certain that one most important element in their production and maintenance is the continual movement and friction of the affected parts. But there is little doubt that the moving muscles are involved in the inflammatory process, as Dr. Inman has correctly observed. It would seem plain that under these circumstances – an inflamed muscular structure forced to perform its ordinary contractions as well as it can – there must be powerful dynamic perturbation going on.
If perturbation of nerve-function – a disturbance quite different from mere exaltation of the normal development of nerve-force – be the essence of pain, how comes it that pains of the severest type may be produced by changes in structures which are usually described, for practical purposes, as lying outside the nervous system? We must, in the first place, remark that the externality of any bodily tissue to the nervous system is more apparent than real. Microscopic researches are constantly revealing nerve-fibres, in ever-increasing profusion, which penetrate to parts seemingly the least vitalized in the organism. But, in any case, the nerves are certainly the ultimate channel of communication between the suffering part and the sentient centre. It seems, therefore, the inevitable conclusion that a dynamic perturbation going on in the non-nervous tissue is continued along the nerves themselves: and that the severity of the pain perceived by the conscious centres is proportionate to the tumultuousness, the want of coordination, and the waste with which force is being evolved in the cramped muscle, or whatever structure it may be, in which the pain takes its source.
Not to pursue these topics further, we may sum up the considerations which have now been adduced, in the following general propositions, which will tend to simplify the examination of the various painful disorders which we are about to discuss:
1. Pain is not a true hyperæsthesia; on the contrary, it involves a lowering of true function.
2. Pain is due to a perturbation of nerve-force, originating in dynamic disturbance either within or without the nervous system.
3. The susceptibility to this perturbation is great in proportion to the physical imperfection of the nervous tissue, until this imperfection reaches to the extent of cutting off nervous communications (paralysis).
PART I.
ON NEURALGIA
CHAPTER I.
CLINICAL HISTORY
Neuralgia may be defined as a disease of the nervous system, manifesting itself by pains which, in the great majority of cases, are unilateral, and which appear to follow accurately the course of particular nerves, and ramify, sometimes into a few, sometimes into all, the terminal branches of those nerves. These pains are usually sudden in their onset, and of a darting, stabbing, boring, or burning character; they are at first unattended with any local change, or any general febrile excitement. They are always markedly intermittent, at any rate at first; the intermissions are sometimes regular, and sometimes irregular; the attacks commonly go on increasing in severity on each successive occasion. The intermissions are distinguished by complete, or almost complete, freedom from suffering, and in recent cases the patient appears to be quite well at these times; except that, for some short time after the attack, the parts through which the painful nerves ramify remain sore, and tender to the touch. In old-standing cases, however, persistent tenderness, and other signs of local mischief, are apt to be developed in the tissues around the peripheral twigs. Severe neuralgias are usually complicated with secondary affections of other nerves which are intimately connected with those that are the original seat of pain; and in this way congestions of blood vessels, hypersecretion or arrested secretion from glands, inflammation and ulceration of tissues, etc., are sometimes brought about.
The above is a general description of neuralgia which will identify the disease sufficiently for the purpose of introducing it the attention of the reader. We must now proceed to give a more accurate account of its
Clinical History and Symptoms.– These vary so greatly in different kinds of neuralgia that it will be necessary to discuss the greater part of this subject under the headings of the special varieties of the disease. There are certain common features, however, in all true neuralgias.
I. In the first place, it is universally the case that the condition of the patient, at the time of the first attack, is one of debility, either general or special. I make this assertion with confidence, notwithstanding that Valleix, and some other very able observers, have made a contrary statement. In the first place, it is certainly the case that the larger half of the total number of cases of neuralgia which come under my care are either decidedly anæmic, or else have recently undergone some exhausting illness or fatigue; and if other writers have failed to see so many neuralgic patients in whom these conditions were present, it must certainly be because they have limited the application of the term "neuralgia" within bounds which are too narrow to be justified by any logical argument; as will, indeed, be shown at a later stage. On the other hand, although a considerable number of neuralgic patients have an externally healthy appearance, as indicated by a ruddy complexion and a fair amount of muscular development, it cannot be admitted that these appearances exclude the possibility of debility, either structional or functional, of the nervous system. The commonest experience might teach us that, so far from the nervous system being invariably developed with a corresponding completeness and maintained with a corresponding vigor to those which distinguish the muscular system and the organs of vegetative life, there is often a very striking contrast between these in the same individual. What physician is there who has not seen epileptic patients, in whom mental habitude, a low cranial development, imperfect cutaneous sensibility, and other obvious marks of deficient innervation, were marked and striking features at, or even before, the first occurrence of convulsive symptoms, while the body was robust, the face well colored, and the muscular power up to or beyond the average? Now, it will invariably be found, on carefully sifting the history of apparently robust neuralgic patients, that they, too, have given previous indications of weakness of the nervous system: thus, women, who, after a severe confinement attended with great loss of blood, are attached with clavus hystericus or with migraine; will inform us that whenever, in earlier life, they suffered from headache, the pain was on the same side as that now affected, and chiefly or altogether confined to the site of the present neuralgia. In a considerable number of cases, also, in which I have been able to observe accurately the events which preceded an attack of neuralgia, it has been found that the skin supplied by the nerves about to become painful was anæsthesic to a remarkable degree; and it is very often the case that a more moderate amount of blunted sensation was perceptible in these parts during the intervals between attacks of pain. A somewhat delusive appearance of general nervous vigor is often conveyed to the observer of neuralgic patients, by reason of the intellectual and emotional characteristics of the latter. Both ideation and emotion are, indeed, very often quick and active in the victims of neuralgia, who in this respect differ strikingly from the majority of epileptics. But this mobility of the higher centres of the nervous system is itself no sign of general nervous strength; which last can never be possessed except by those in whom a certain balance of the various nervous functions is maintained. Much more will be said on this topic when we come to discuss the etiology of neuralgia. Meantime I may content myself with repeating the fact which is indubitably taught by careful observation – that neuralgics are invariably marked by some original weakness of the nervous system; though in some cases this defect is confined strictly to that part of the sensory system which ultimately becomes the seat of neuralgic pain.
Another circumstance is common to all neuralgias of superficial nerves; and, as a large majority of all neuralgias are superficial in situation, this is, for practical purposes, a general characteristic of the disease. I refer to the gradual formation of tender spots at various points where the affected nerves pass from a deeper to a more superficial level, and particularly where they emerge from bony canals, or pierce fibrous fasciæ. So general is this characteristic of inveterate neuralgias, that Valleix founded his diagnosis of the genuine neuralgias on the presence of these painful points. Herein he appears to me to be decidedly in error. I have watched a great many cases (of all sorts of varieties as to the situation of the pain), and I have uniformly observed that in the early stages firm pressure may be made on the painful nerve without any aggravation of the pain; indeed, very often with the effect of assuaging it. The formation of tender spots is a subsequent affair: they develop in those situations which have been the foci, or severest points, of the neuralgic pain. There is however, a point which, though not always, nor often, the seat of spontaneous pain, is nevertheless very generally tender. Trousseau, who criticises unfavorably the statement of Valleix as to the situation of the points douloureux, insists that this tender spot, which is over the spinous processes of the vertebræ corresponding to the origin of the painful nerve, and which he calls the points apophysaire, is more universally present than any of those pointed out by Valleix. I shall hereafter endeavor to show that these spinal points are by no means characteristic of neuralgia; they are present in a variety of affections which were ably described, under the heading of "Spinal Irritation," many years ago, by the brothers Griffin. ["Observations on the Functional Affections of the Spinal Cord," by William and Daniel Griffin. London, 1834] and they are also present with misleading frequency in cases of mere myalgia, such as I shall have to describe at a later stage.
Another characteristic of neuralgic patients in general is, I believe, a certain mobility of the vaso-motor nervous system and of the cardiac motor nerves; but I insist less on this than on the above-named features, because a more extended experience is necessary to establish the fact with certainty. Within my own experience it has always seemed to be the case that persons who are liable to neuralgia are specially prone to sudden changes of vascular tension, under emotional and other influences which operate strongly on the nervous system. The observation of this fact has been made accidentally, without any previous bias on my part, in the course of a large number of experiments made upon individuals free from manifest disease at the time, with Marey's sphygmograph.
Neuralgic attacks are always intermittent, or at the least remittent, in every stage of the disease.
The manner in which neuralgic pain commences is characteristic and important. There is always a degree of suddenness in its outset. When produced by a violent shock, it may, and often does, spring into full development and severity at once, of which, perhaps, the most striking example is the sudden and violent neuralgic pain of the eyebrow which some persons experience from swallowing a lump of undissolved ice. Usually, however, the first warning is a sudden, not very severe, and altogether transient dart of pain. The patient has probably been suffering from some degree of general fatigue and malaise, and the skin of the affected part has been somewhat numb, when a sudden slight stitch of pain darts into the nerve at some point which corresponds to one of the foci hereafter to be particularized. It ceases immediately, but in a few seconds or minutes returns; and these darts of pain recur more and more frequently, till at last they blend themselves together in such a manner that the patient suffers continuous and violent pain for a minute or so, then experiences a short intermission, and then the pain returns again, and so on. These intermittent spasms of pain go on recurring for one or several hours; then the intermissions become longer, the pain slighter, and at last the attack wears itself out. Such is generally the history of first attacks, especially in subjects who are not past the middle age, nor particularly debilitated from any special cause.
A point of interest in connection with the natural history of the neuralgic access is the condition of the circulation. The commencement of pain is generally preceded by paleness of skin and sensations of chilliness. At the commencement of the painful paroxysm, sphygmographic observation shows that the arterial tension is much increased, owing, in all probability, to spasm of the small vessels. This condition is gradually replaced by an opposite state, the pulse becoming large, soft, and bounding, though very unresisting, and giving a sphygmographic trace which exhibits marked dicrotism. Simultaneously with this the skin becomes warmer, sometimes even uncomfortably warm, and there is frequently considerable flushing of the face.
The final characteristic common to all neuralgias is that fatigue, and every other depressing influence, directly predispose to an attack, and aggravate it when already existing.
Varieties.– It is possible to classify neuralgias upon either of two systems: first (a), according to the constitutional state of the patient; and, secondly (b), according to the situation of the affected nerves. It will be necessary to follow both these lines of classification, avoiding all needless repetition.
(a) In considering the influence of constitutional states upon the typical development of neuralgia, it will be convenient to commence with the group of cases in which the general condition of the organism produces the least effect. This is the case when the pain is the result of direct injury to a nerve-trunk, whether by external violence, by the mechanical pressure of a tumor, or by the involvement of a nerve in inflammatory or ulcerative processes originating in a neighboring part. As regards the development of symptoms, the important matters are, that the pain in these cases commences comparatively gradually, that the intermissions are usually more or less complete, and that the pain is far less amenable to relief from remedies, than in other forms of neuralgia. The little that can be said about the form which is dependent upon progressively increasing pressure, or involvement of a nerve in malignant ulcerations, caries of bones or teeth, etc., falls under the heads of Diagnosis and Treatment, and need not detain us here. The clinical history of neuralgia from external violence, however, requires separate discussion:
1. Neuralgia from external shock may be produced by a physical cause (as by a fall, a railway collision, etc.), which gives a jar to the central nervous system; or by severe mental emotion, operating upon the same part of the organism. Under either of these circumstances the development of the affection may occur at once, but by far the most frequently it ensues after a variable interval, during which the patient shows signs of general depression, with loss of appetite and strength. Sometimes vomiting, and in other instances paralysis, of a partial and temporary kind, occur. When once developed, the neuralgic attacks do not differ from those which proceed from causes internal to the organism. In the greater number of instances, so far as my experience goes, it is the fifth cranial nerve which becomes neuralgic from the effects of central shock. Illustrative cases will be given in the section on Local Classification. Meantime the important facts to note, in relation to the influence of constitutional states, are these: In the first place, the tendency of such accidents to excite neuralgia varies directly with the hereditary predisposition evinced by the liability of the sufferer's family to neuralgic affections and to the more serious neuroses. Secondly, the likelihood of a neuralgic attack is indefinitely increased if he has already had neuralgia. Thirdly, although debility from temporary and special causes can rarely be sufficient to insure a true neuralgic access after a severe shock, it probably heightens, indefinitely, the tendency in a person otherwise predisposed. Delicate women are many times more liable to experience such consequences, from a physical or mental shock, than men of tolerably robust constitution.
2. Neuralgia from direct violence to superficial nerves is produced by cutting or, more rarely, by bruising wounds. Cutting wounds may divide a nerve-trunk (a) partially, or (b) completely.
(a) When a nerve-trunk is partially cut through, neuralgic pain occurs, if at all, immediately, or almost immediately, on the receipt of the injury. One such instance only has come under my own care, but many others are recorded. In my case the ulnar nerve was partly cut through, with a tolerably sharp bread-knife, not far above the wrist; partial anæsthesia of the little and ring fingers was induced, but at the same time violent neuralgic pains in the little finger came on, in fits recurring several times a day, and lasting about half a minute. Treatment was of little apparent effect in promoting a cure; though opiates and the local use of chloroform afforded temporary relief. The attacks recurred for more than a month, long after the original wound had healed soundly; and, for a long time after this, pressure on the cicatrix would reproduce the attacks. A slight amount of anæsthesia still remained, when I saw the patient more than a year after the injury.
(b) Complete severance of a nerve-trunk is a sufficiently common accident, far more common then is neuralgia produced by such a cause; indeed, so marked is this disproportion between the injury and the special result, that I have been led to infer that a necessary factor in the chain of morbid events must be the existence of some antecedent peculiarity in the central origin of the injured nerve. This opinion is rendered the more probable because the consecutive neuralgia is in some cases situated, not in the injured nerve itself, but in some other nerve with which it has central connections. Two such cases are recorded in my Lettsomian Lectures, [Lancet, 1866], in which the ulnar nerve, and one in which the cervico-occipital, were completely divided; in all three the resulting neuralgia was developed in the branches of the fifth cranial. Here we may suppose that the weak point existed in the central nucleus of the fifth; and that the irritation, or rather depression, communicated to the whole spinal centres by the wound of a distant nerve, first found, on reaching this weak point, the necessary conditions for the development of the neuralgic form of pain, which therefore would be represented to the mental perception as present in the peripheral branches of the fifth nerve. In all the cases which have come under my notice, the neuralgia set in at a particular period, namely, after complete cicatrization of the wound, and while the functions of the branches on the peripheral side of the wound were partly, but not completely, restored. The same obstinacy and rebelliousness to treatment are observed as in other instances of neuralgia from injury.
CHAPTER II.
COMPLICATIONS OF NEURALGIA
The secondary affections which may arise as complications of neuralgia form a deeply interesting chapter in nervous pathology, and one which has only been explored in quite recent years. The excellent treatises of Valleix and Romberg, written only thirty years ago, make but most cursory and superficial mention of these complications, and do not attempt to group them in a scientific manner. The reflex convulsive movement of the facial muscles in severe tic-douloureux had of course been long observed; and Valleix added the correct observation that gastric disturbance was often secondarily provoked in facial neuralgia, thus improving greatly on the old view, which supposed that, where trigeminal neuralgia and stomach disorder coexisted, the latter must have been the antecedent and the cause of the former. Still, he did not explain the pathological connection. And as regards certain other most interesting results of neuralgia, which he could not avoid meeting with from time to time, e. g., lachrymation, flux from the nostril, salivation, altered nutrition of the hair, he only speaks of these as occasional phenomena, and in no way classifies them, or explains their relation to the neuralgia itself.
There did exist, however, one too little known work of some years earlier date, which, though not dealing specifically with neuralgia, and though based upon the necessarily very imperfect knowledge of the functions of the nervous system prevalent in its day, had nevertheless done much to lay the foundation of a comprehensive view of the complications of neuralgia; we refer to the work of the brothers Griffin, on "Functional Affections of the Spinal Cord and Ganglionic System," published in 1834. In this most interesting treatise, the record of acute and extensive observations made in a quiet and unpretending way by two Irish practitioners, numerous examples are cited in which neuralgic affections were seen to be inseparably united with secondary affections of the most various organs, with which the neuralgic nerves could have no connection except through the centres, by reflex action. The authors, while firmly grasping the fact of the common connection of the nerve-pain and the other phenomena (convulsions, paralysis, altered special sensation, changes in secretion, changes even in the nutrition of particular tissues) with the central nerve system, were doubtless in error in thinking that they could detect the precise seat of the original malady, by discovering certain points of tenderness over the spinal column. But their facts were observed with the greatest care, and can now be interpreted more intelligently than was possible at the time. Here, for example, is a case which forestalls one of the most interesting pieces of information which more recent research has made generally known:
"Case XXIV. – Kitty Hanley, aged fourteen years, catamenia never appeared; about six months ago was attacked with pain in the right eye and brow, occurring only at night, and then so violently as to make her scream out and disturb every one in the house; it afterward occurred in the infra-orbital nerve, and along the lower jaw in the teeth, and there was inflammation of the cornea, with superficial ulceration and slight muddiness. Tenderness was found at the upper cervical vertebræ, pressure on any of them exciting severe pain in the vertex and brow; but none in the eye or jaws, where it is never felt except at night."
The above is a well-marked example of neuralgia of the trigeminus causing secondary inflammation and ulceration of the eye of a precisely similar kind to that which had been experimentally produced by Magendie by section of the fifth, at or posterior to its Gasserian ganglion. We shall see, hereafter, how extremely important are this and similar facts, not only in regard to the clinical history, but also to the pathology of neuralgia in general.
The first regular attempt, I believe, to classify the complications of neuralgia, was made by M. Notta, in a series of elaborate papers in the "Archives Generales de Medecine" for 1854. We may specially mention his analysis of a hundred and twenty-eight cases of trigeminal neuralgia, which is well fitted to impress on the mind the frequency, though, as we shall presently see, it does not adequately represent the seriousness, of these secondary disorders. As regards special senses, Notta says that the retina was completely or almost completely paralyzed in ten cases, and in nine others vision was interfered with, partly, probably, from impaired function of the retina, but partly, also, from dilatation of the pupil or other functional derangement independent of the optic nerve. The sense of hearing was impaired in four cases. The sense of taste was perverted in one case, and abolished in another. As regards secretion, lachrymation was observed in sixty-one cases, or nearly half the total number. Nasal secretion was repressed in one case, in ten others it was increased on the affected side. Unilateral sweating is spoken of more doubtfully, but is said to have been probably present in a considerable number of cases. In eight instances there was decided unilateral redness of the face, and five times this was attended with noticeable tumefaction. In one case the unilateral tumefaction and redness persisted, and were, in fact, accompanied by a general hypertrophy of the tissues. Dilatation of the conjunctival vessels was observed in thirty-four cases. Nutrition was affected as follows: In four cases there was unilateral hypertrophy of the tissues; in two, the hair was hypertrophied at the ends, and in several others it was observed to fall out or to turn gray. The tongue was greatly tumefied in one case. Muscular contractions, on the affected side, were noted in fifty-two cases. Permanent tonic spasm, not due to photophobia, was observed in the eyelid in four cases, in the muscles of mastication four times, in the muscles of the external ear once. Paralysis affected the motor oculi, causing prolapse of the upper eyelid, in six cases; in half of these there was also outward squint. In two instances the facial muscles were paralyzed in a purely reflex manner. The pupil was dilated in three cases, and contracted in two others, without any impairment of sight; in three others it was dilated, with considerable diminution of the visual power. Finally, with regard to common sensibility, M. Notta reports three cases in which anæsthesia was observed. Hyperæsthesia of the surface only occurred in the latter stages of the disease.
To Notta's list of complications of trigeminal neuralgia must be added the following, all of which have been witnessed, and several of them in a large number of instances: Iritis, glaucoma, corneal clouding, and even ulceration; periostitis, unilateral furring of the tongue, herpes unilateralis, etc. In writing on this subject three or four years ago, I mentioned that all these secondary affections had been seen by myself, except glaucoma. That is now no longer an exception; indeed, my attention has been so forcibly called to the connection between glaucoma and facial neuralgia, that I shall presently examine it at some length.
The trigeminus is, of all nerves in the body, that one whose affections are likely to cause secondary disturbances of wide extent and various nature, owing to its large peripheral expanse, the complex nature of its functions, and its extensive and close connections with other nerves. Moreover, its relations to so important and noticeable an organ as the eye tends to call our attention strongly to the phenomena that attend its perturbations. But there is every reason to think that all secondary complications which may attend trigeminal neuralgia are represented by analogous secondary affections in neuralgias in all kinds of situations; and we may classify them in the principal groups which correspond to disturbance of large sets of functions:
1. First, and on the whole, probably, the most common of all secondary affections, we may rank some degree of vaso-motor paralysis. It may be doubted if neuralgia ever reaches more than a very slight degree without involving more or less of this; for so-called points douloureux are themselves pretty certainly, for the most part, a phenomenon of vaso-motor palsy; and the more widely-diffused soreness, such as remains in the scalp, for instance, after attacks of pain, even at an earlier stage of trigeminal neuralgia than that in which permanently tender points are formed, is probably entirely due to a temporary skin-congestion. The phenomenon presents itself in a much more striking way in the condition of the conjunctiva seen in intense attacks of neuralgia affecting the ocular and peri-ocular branches of the fifth; one sometimes finds the whole conjunctiva deeply crimson; and, in one remarkable instance that I observed, the same shade of intense red colored the mucous membrane of the nostril of the same side. In several instances, I have seen a more than usually violent attack of sciatic pain followed by the development of a pale, rosy blush over the thinner parts of the skin of the leg, especially of the calf, which were then extremely tender, in a diffuse manner, for some time after spontaneous pain had ceased.
2. Not merely the circulation, however, but the nutrition of tissues, becomes positively affected, in a considerable number of cases. It is difficult to judge, with any exactness, in what proportion of neuralgic cases this occurs, but its slighter degrees must be very common. It has very frequently happened to me, quite accidentally, in examining with some care the fixed painful points, which are so important in diagnosis, to be struck with the decided evidence to the finger of solid thickening, evidently dependent on hypertrophic development of tissue-elements; in severe and long-standing cases, I believe this condition will always be found. Probably the change is, more usually than not, sub-inflammatory; but it is certain, on the other hand, that there are great variations in the kind of tissue-changes complicating neuralgia, and that inflammation is no necessary element in them. This subject has greatly engaged my attention, and I find myself able to give what is probably a fuller account of the matter than any yet published connectedly.
The following tissues have been seen by myself to become altered under the influence of neuralgia in nerves distributed to them, or to the parts in their immediate neighborhood.
(a) The hair has changed in color in many cases. Of twenty-seven patients suffering from neuralgia of the ophthalmic division of the fifth, eleven had more or less decided localized grayness of hair on that side. The amount of this varied greatly, from mere patches of gray near the roots of the hair to decided grayness of the majority of the hairs over the larger part of half the head, nearly to the vertex; but in each case it was a change of color that did not exist on the other side of the head. In four of these cases there was also grayness of part of the eyebrow on the affected side. A very remarkable phenomenon, which I have sometimes identified, is fluctuation of the color, the grayness notably increasing during, and for some time after, an acute attack of pain, and the same hairs returning afterward more or less to their original color. My attention was first called to this curious occurrence in my own case. I have so often related this case [see, for instance, my article on Neuralgia in "Reynolds's System of Medicine," vol. ii.] that I shall merely recall the fact that, when pain attacks me severely, the hair of the eyebrow on the affected side displays a very distinct patch of gray (on some occasions it has been quite white) opposite the tissue of the supra-orbital nerve, and that the same hairs (which can be easily identified) return almost to the natural color when I am free from neuralgia. I must, however, add the very curious fact, which I observed accidentally in experimenting (as regards urinary elimination) on the effects of large doses of alcohol, that a dose sufficiently large to produce uncomfortably narcotic effects invariably caused the same temporary change of color in the hair of the same eyebrow, even when no decided pain was produced, but only general malaise. The subject will be again referred to under the heading of Pathology.
Change in the size and texture of the hairs, in neuralgia, has been noted by Romberg and Notta, and has been several times observed by myself. Occasionally the individual hairs near the distribution of the painful nerve become coarsely hypertrophied; at times the number of hairs appears to multiply, but I imagine this is only a case of more rapid and exuberant development of hairs that would be otherwise weak and small. In one very remarkable instance of sciatica this came under my observation; the whole front of the painful leg, from the knee nearly to the ankle, became clothed, in the course of about six months, with a dense fell of hair, which strongly reminded me of similar abnormal hair-growths that have been occasionally seen in connection with traumatic injuries to the spinal cord. More commonly, the effect of neuralgia upon hair is to make it brittle, and to cause it to fall out in considerable quantities; one young lady, who consulted me for a severe migraine, was seriously afraid of having a good head of hair completely ruined in this way, but the hair gradually grew again after the neuralgia had disappeared.
(b) The periosteum of bone and the fibrous fasciæ in the neighborhood of the painful points of neuralgic nerves not unfrequently take on a condition of subacute inflammation, with marked thickening and tenderness on pressure. The most striking instance of this that I have seen was in a lady suffering from severe cervico-brachial neuralgia. In the neighborhood of the emergence of the musculo-spiral nerve at the outer side of the arm, there was developed what looked for all the world like a large syphilitic node, except that the skin was brightly reddened over it; this disappeared altogether some little time after the neuralgia had been relieved by ordinary treatment. I must say that, but for the peculiar circumstances of the case, putting syphilis out of the question, I could not have avoided the suspicion, at first, that the swelling was specific. But I have several times seen similar, though less developed, swellings in neuralgia, and in one case I noticed the occurrence of such a swelling on the malar bone, in an old woman in whom the neuralgic pain was limited to the auriculo-temporal and the supra-orbital branches of the fifth.
A very important point is to be noted in connection with these sub-inflammatory swellings in connection with neuralgia. Pressure on them will, frequently, not merely excite the neuralgic pains in the branches of the affected nerve, but send a powerful reflex influence through the cord to distant organs, causing vomiting, for instance, or affecting the action of the heart in a very perceptible manner. I shall show, when I come to speak of the phenomena of so-called spinal irritation, that this circumstance has led to erroneous influences in many cases. These exquisitely tender points are often found where Trousseau places his neuralgic point apophysaire, namely, over, or very near, the spinous processes of the vertebræ. The tenderness is quite unlike that which is known as hysterical hyperæsthesia; it is much severer, and is limited to one, two, or three points, corresponding, in fact, to the superficial part of the posterior branches of as many spinal nerves.
(c) The nutrition of the skin over neuralgic nerves is sometimes notably affected even when the process does not reach the truly inflammatory stage, which will be more particularly mentioned presently. A certain coarseness of texture of the skin has struck me much, in several cases of long-standing facial neuralgia. And there is a most curious phenomenon (which will be especially considered hereafter in regard to the singular influence of the constant galvanic current upon it), the distribution of a greater or less amount of dark pigment to the skin near the painful part. This phenomenon is much more marked during the paroxysms, and in the slighter cases entirely disappears in the intervals, but in old-standing severe cases it becomes more or less permanent.
(d) The mucous membranes, in situations where we can observe them, not unfrequently show interesting changes, the nutrition of the epithelium of parts covering the painful nerve being exaggerated. It has been noted by various observers, in neuralgia affecting the second and third divisions of the trigeminus, that the half of the tongue corresponding to the painful nerve was covered with a dense fur. This is by no means universally the case, but I have seen it occur several times. In my own case, in which the neuralgia is limited for the most part to the ophthalmic division, and only rarely spreads even to the second division of the nerve, this does not usually occur, but I have noticed it on one or two occasions. And I once made the still more singular observation that a large narcotic dose of alcohol, which was sufficient to cause comparatively free elimination of unchanged alcohol in the urine, caused furring of the tongue, which was decidedly thicker on the side of the affected nerve than on the other half of the tongue.
(e) We come now to a group of complications of neuralgia which are exceedingly important, and by no means adequately appreciated as yet, viz., the acute inflammations which directly result from neuralgic affections in a certain percentage of cases, probably much larger than has been at all generally suspected.
The most familiar of the inflammatory complications of neuralgia is herpes zoster, the favorite seat of which is the skin which covers one or more of the intercostal spaces: the eruption, as occurring in this situation, is so well known that it would be waste of time to describe it. In young subjects zoster is commonly painless, at least the sensations are those of heat, pricking, and irritation, rather than of acute pain; but from puberty onward there is an increasing tendency, especially in those otherwise predisposed to neuralgia, for zoster to be preceded, accompanied, or followed by neuralgia of the intercostal nerves corresponding to the distribution of the eruption. Most commonly, the eruptive period is, in my experience, nearly or quite free from neuralgia, but it often recurs, or breaks out for the first time, when the vesicles are drying up, but more especially if, as is sometimes the case, especially in elderly people, the scabs fall off and leave superficial ulcers. Neuralgia may last, after herpes zoster, for any time from a few days to many weeks, and I have known it so agonizingly severe and so persistent as actually to kill an aged woman from sheer exhaustion. In spite of sundry objections that have been raised to the theory of the nervous origin of zoster, it appears to me that the evidence in favor of it is overwhelming, more especially now that it is proved that the disease, with all the same characteristics presented by it when seen on the chest or abdomen, may occur on the face (following the branches of the trigeminus), or on the forearm (following the course of nerves from the brachial plexus). Two of the severest cases of neuralgia attending herpes that I have ever seen were in private patients (whose family history, unfortunately, I had no means of ascertaining) who were affected, respectively, in the facial and in the brachial nerve-territories.
A far more formidable occasional complication of neuralgia is inflammation affecting the eye. Mr. Jonathan Hutchinson records several cases in which neuralgic herpes zoster of the face was attended with iritis, with serious or even irremediable damage to the organ. For my own part, I have witnessed several instances in which neuralgia of the first and second divisions of the fifth has been attended with skin-inflammation, but only in one of these (just alluded to) did the inflammation present the characteristic appearances of herpes: in all the rest it far more closely resembled erysipelas. The skin was excessively reddened in an almost or quite continuous patch over the whole territory through which ran the painful nerves; by no means only linearly in the course of the nerves, though accurately limited to the district of the first or first and second divisions of the fifth. In the first case I saw (a woman, aged thirty-two), nothing could be more startling than the rapidity with which an irregular patch of the skin, including half of one cheek, the side of the nose, and a large part of the forehead and scalp on the same side, became converted into the dense, fiery-red, brawny tissue, with minute vesicles scattered over its surface, which looks so characteristic of erysipelas; this commenced immediately on the subsidence of severe neuralgic pain. During the erysipelatoid inflammation, though there was no spontaneous pain, the neuralgia could be instantly lighted up for a moment by pressure on the infra-orbital foramen, on the supra-orbital notch, or upon the malar bone, about its centre. Since that time I have seen several cases of a similar character; two of these, which were reported in the Lancet for 1866, I shall here reproduce: [Extensive inquiries convinced me that the tendency to erysipelatous complication of facial neuralgia is exceedingly common. Eulenburg expressly confirms my original statement to this effect, and extends it to all neuralgias.]
Case I. – A woman, aged sixty-three, presented herself in the out-patient room at Westminster Hospital, suffering from neuralgia of ten days' standing (which for the present, however, seemed to have abated considerably), but asking advice chiefly for an erysipelatoid inflammation which had come on a day or two before, and occupied the area of the painful nerve-district. The neuralgia had affected the supra-orbital nerve, running up toward the vortex, and the auriculo-temporal branch of the third division of the fifth; although there was no very acute pain present at this time, pressure over the supra-orbital notch, or at a point just in front of the ear, would at once cause a brief paroxysm of pain. It was curious to find that there was a thickened and tender spot over the malar bone (and corresponding to the exit of some nerve filaments from the bone) which had never been the seat of spontaneous neuralgia, but pressure here sent a dart of pain into the auriculo-temporal and supra-orbital nerves. The inflammation was markedly limited to the general area of distribution of the twigs of the auriculo-temporal and of the ophthalmic division; it was of a continuous deep-red color, and attended with much thickening of the skin. The conjunctiva was intensely congested, and there were lachrymation and very marked photophobia, but there were no signs of iritis, and no corneal clouding.
Case II. – M. W., a woman, aged forty-two, well-nourished and healthy-looking, married and had one child; had never suffered any serious ailment except once, about five years previously. She then had a decided attack of "erysipelas," very accurately limited to the right half of the face. Five months before coming to me she sustained a severe shock from being thrown out of a chaise, without suffering any external or visible damage. An hysterical tendency, which she had always possessed, became more marked; it revealed itself by palpitations, occasional dysphagia, and a disposition to weep causelessly. The menses were flowing at the time of the accident; they ceased abruptly soon after (they had been scanty for some time previously), and did not recur till four months later. The hysteric disturbance progressively increased during a fortnight, and then the patient was attacked with violent intermittent neuralgia, commencing in the eyeball and spreading over the district supplied by the branches of the first and second divisions of the trigeminus. The pain was accompanied by intense conjunctival congestion and photophobia [Dr. Handfield Jones remarks that photophobia, in his experience, is only a rare accompaniment of facial neuralgia. I have latterly come to the same opinion. Redness of the eye and lachrymation are very common; true photophobia uncommon. Notta's experience would seem to have been similar]. It lasted on the first day fourteen hours, and returned daily for the next fifteen or sixteen days. An attack of erysipelas, strictly limited to the district of the painful nervous branches, then set in. From that moment the neuralgic attacks became less frequent and severe. A second similar onset of erysipelas occurred some three or four weeks after the first. Finally, the neuralgia disappeared about four months after its first occurrence, and the menses reappeared in tolerable abundance about the same time. About a fortnight before this the patient had discovered that her right eye was dim; as the photophobia had previously disabled her from opening the eye, she could not be sure how long this dimness had existed. At the time of her visit to me the cornea was blurred with a large patch of interstitial lymph, with the remains of a superficial ulcer in the centre; the iris was turbid and discolored, showing the traces of recent but past iritis; the pupil was regular in form and active to light; the conjunctiva was slightly congested. Ophthalmoscopic observation was attempted by a skilled observer, but could not be satisfactorily carried out, from the turbid state of the media. The conjunctiva was slightly congested. In place of the lachrymation that had prevailed during the neuralgic period, there was a remarkable insensibility of the lachrymal apparatus, for the patient had noticed that the smell of onions, which would make the other eye weep profusely, had no influence on the affected one.
The family history of this patient is a most remarkable one. All the members of her mother's family, for two generations back, had died at middle age, either from apoplexy or some disease involving hemiplegia. This case has, by a mistake, not been added to the list of twenty-two private cases in which the family history was carefully investigated, that will be found in the chapter on Pathology; this arose from the fact that the patient was not properly under my care, but was sent to me as a medical curiosity; the notes of her case were therefore taken in a different book from the others. The case certainly ought to be taken as a counterpoise to such a one as No. XVI. in the list, which is that of a gentleman who suffered from the most complicated neurotic maladies (asthma, angina pectoris, facial neuralgia, more than once attended with erysipelas), but whose family history, so far as it was known, presented no traces of tendency to neurotic disease.
To these two cases of inflammation, secondary to neuralgia, I shall add a third, which is even more interesting, and which came under my notice not long since.
Case III. – H. T., watchmaker's assistant, aged forty-two, suffered for about three weeks with very severe remittent abdominal pain, entirely unconnected with dyspepsia, constipation, or diarrhœa. It was intermittent in character, but observation soon showed that the times at which it came on were simply those at which the stomach had gone longest without food, especially the early morning, and that nourishment never failed to relieve it. The suffering was great, and the man failed considerably in general health, notwithstanding that his appetite and digestion were unimpaired. He had only been under my care about ten days when he presented himself one day at the hospital, and stated that the pains in the stomach had entirely left him, but that he suffered the most frightful pains in and around the right eye. I found a well-marked conjunctival congestion and lachrymation, but there were as yet no tender points; the neuralgia was felt most severely in the globe of the eye and in one tolerably straight line, darting up toward the vertex from the brow. The iris seemed clear and free, and the cornea was not cloudy. I gave the man a subcutaneous injection of one-sixth grain acetate of morphia, for present ease, and ordered him muriate of iron and small doses of strychnia three times a day. When he next appeared, four days later, I was alarmed to perceive that unmistakable iritis had fully developed itself, the iris was already turbid and discolored and the pupil irregular, from a serious amount of adhesions. By this time there were fully-developed tender points, supra-orbital and parietal; besides this, pressure on the globe caused paroxysms of pain, in all the branches of the ophthalmic division, but there was not much spontaneous pain. I dropped atropine in the eye, applied blistering fluid to the back of the neck, [the nape of the neck is the point most suitable for blistering which is intended to affect the eye, and the ophthalmic division of the fifth, generally,] and desired the man to come to see me at my own house next day, intending to take him to an ophthalmic surgeon. Unfortunately he failed to do this, and three days later, when he came to see me at the hospital, the cornea was studded with opacities, the pupil was almost closed with effused lymph, there was violent ocular pain, and a great and increasing sense of tension. I begged him to go without loss of time to the Eye Hospital, as my own ophthalmic colleague was not at Westminster that day; and I have never heard any more of the patient.
Glaucoma is a still more serious disease of the eye, which I think there is now sufficient evidence to show is sometimes entirely, and very often in considerable part, neuralgic in its origin. Since my attention was directed, some six years ago, to the frequent connection between the so-called rheumatic iritis and neuralgia, I have taken much interest in the subject of acute eye-affections; and the occurrence of one or two cases of glaucoma in personal friends of my own has made this interest even painfully strong. I am necessarily without the means of personally observing glaucoma on the large scale, but I have now seen two cases in which, if I possess any faculty of clinical observation whatever, the whole genesis of the disease was a neuralgic disorder of the trigeminus; and it was to me a melancholy reflection that nothing better than iridectomy in one case, and excision of the eyeball in the other, could be done in the present state of ophthalmic science. There are now a good many recorded instances of neuralgic glaucoma, and Mr. R. Brudenell Carter, of St. George's, and the South London Ophthalmic Hospital, recently assured me that nervous aspect of some form of glaucoma presents itself the strongly to his mind, though he does not commit himself to any theory. Two cases were reported by Mr. Hutchinson, in Ophthalmic Hospital Reports IV. and V.; but the most complete and interesting cases that I have met with are recorded by Dr. Wegner;15 they are two out of four that occurred within a very short time in the clinic of Prof. Horner at Zurich, and they form the basis of some researches by Wegner into the nature of the influence of the trigeminus upon ocular tension, which will be referred to, along with others, in the chapter on Pathology. The second of these cases is so important that I shall reproduce it in full.
A. Hediger, aged twenty-four, a moderately strongly-built young woman, seen first in August, 1860. From her own and her mother's account, it seemed she had long suffered from convulsive attacks that did not appear to have been truly epileptic. Some days previously her left eye became very painful, and the sight failed, without any inflammatory symptoms. On inspection the pupil was somewhat dilated, the eye somewhat hypermetropic, fundus normal; No. 5, Jager's type, was read with difficulty. Wegner could not explain the condition. At the end of October the eye was much worse; after severe paroxysms of pain, No. 16 type was the smallest legible, the field of vision was decidedly limited in all directions, but especially on the inner and upper portions. An unusually long hysteric attack was now observed. The patient was for twenty-four hours in a half-sleep, the extremities, meantime, were much jerked, the speech sometimes coherent and sometimes incoherent; she cried out to her friends, etc., but had no severe convulsion-fit with spasm of glottis. She was removed to the hospital, where she stayed six weeks. The hysteria improved under treatment with valerian and morphia (Prof. Greisinger had confirmed the opinion that there was no true lesion of the centres), but the neuralgia of the globe was extraordinarily severe, both day and night. From January to June, 1861, Wegner saw her occasionally. The visual power of the left eye fluctuated between 15 and 19 Jager. Field of vision very limited. Pupil very dilated and insensitive, the globe painful to the touch, and injected. The right eye weakly hypermetropic; normal field of vision, normal pupil, no pain. The scene suddenly changed on the 29th of June. She was attacked with fearful pain, and an enormous mydriasis with extreme amblyopia of the right eye; the fingers could hardly be counted when placed quite close. The optic disc appeared somewhat cloudy, with very evident venous pulsation. The mydriasis, amblyopia, and neuralgia lasted some time, while simultaneously the left eye could only read 19-17 type, but was painless. The pathology seemed quite obscure, and the surgeon remained almost passive till August, when he performed paracentesis on the left eye. The patient could distinguish fingers at that time at a foot's distance with the right eye; with the left read No. 11, but suffered fearful pains. These diminished after the puncture; the eye could read No. 20 next day, and improved after that to 19; the pains recurred in the next day, but for the first time ceased to disturb sleep. The scene again changed in the most surprising manner on the 27th of August. The most frightful pain again attacked the left eye. The pupil was dilated to the maximum (far beyond what occurs in oculo-motor paralysis); the globe was extremely painful on touch, visual power fallen to 19 Jager. On the other hand, the right eye had a normal pupil, was painless, and could read No. 12. Paracentesis of the left eye improved its vision and diminished pain, but only temporarily, so that it had to be repeated at short intervals. The condition was so far stationary toward the end of October that the right eye continually gained visual power, but the left stood still and fluctuated from worse to better, with the greater or less severity of the neuralgic paroxysms. Pupils always in extreme dilatation. In the end of October and beginning of November (the patient had worn a large seton for a month) remarkable changes occurred; the neuralgia of the left globe diminished steadily, the pupil got smaller, the visual power increased, the neuralgia now was only on the lower lid, which was slightly red and painful to the touch, and had continual spontaneous pain. Visual power of right eye No. 3, of left eye No. 5. Visual field intact; with full illumination by weak light there is a peripheral torpor, but only in a narrow zone. The hyperæmia now extended more and more over the lower lid and the upper part of the cheek; this was apparent during the paroxysms, which were very severe, and destroyed sleep; it did not allow the skin to be touched; the color was deep (with high temperature) and extended to the angle of the mouth. This phenomenon lasted till the beginning of December, when neuralgia again attacked the left globe, with strong mydriasis and diminution of visual power (15 to 20 Jager), till at last the movements of the hand could hardly be distinguished, and this state of things continued with fluctuations up to the end of the month. The seton had been taken off just before the new outbreak; it was put in again on December 31st. In January the pains continued severe in the eye, with only one remission (from the 17th to the 20th), when the hyperæmia recurred in the cheek. On the 26th the pupil was very dilated, and fingers could not be seen at half a foot's distance. Visual field very limited, globe hard. A large upper iridectomy was made. After this the pupil was contracted, the pains diminished, visual power 10 Jager, field seven inches. In the middle of February the hysterical attacks recurred with great force; the patient was unconscious half the day; she was clear enough in senses when awake, but complained of buzzing in her head, as if a cock-chafer were inside it. From this till the middle of March, the left eye did not alter, the impairment of vision remained, with normal pupil and no pain in the globe, and the iridectomy seemed at least to have done good in one direction; but on the 13th of March the operated eye was again attacked with pain, visual power fell to No. 17, pupil became dilated, and after a few days the swelling, heat, and tenderness of the cheek recurred. During the years 1862 and 1863 the condition remained pretty much the same; i. e., the right eye sound, the left painful (in spite of the iridectomy) with dilated pupil, concentrically narrowed visual field, visual power fluctuating between No. 15 and mere finger-counting without any ophthalmoscopic appearances. A number of paracentesis and subcutaneous injections of morphia (which last were the more indicated as the supra-orbitalis was tender on pressure) always brought relief merely for a few hours. On the 19th of April, 1864, vision being complete in right eye, and No. 19 in left, Wegner punctured the latter. On the 2d of May the eye read No. 10 slowly, the pains had gone and not returned, the pupil became smaller. On the 31st of March, 1865, the patient was pronounced well; the eye was painless, the pupil somewhat larger than the other; the finest type could be read when looked at very close.
3. The next group of affections secondary to neuralgia are the paralysis of muscles. These are pretty common; I find them in twenty-eight of the hundred cases which have been referred to. But of these twenty-eight instances of paralytic affections no less than twelve were connected with neuralgia of the trigeminus, and in most of these it was one or more of the muscles connected with the eye that were affected. Sciatica is nearly always attended with much weakening of voluntary power of the muscles of the thigh and leg; and in some instances this reaches to decided or even complete paralysis. In looking for this phenomenon we must be very careful that we do not mistake the mere reluctance to move the limb, on account of the painfulness of all movements, for true paralytic weakness of nerve and muscle. And it is also necessary to bear in mind, in prolonged cases, the probability that much of the weakness may have been caused by degeneration of the muscles owing to forced inaction. Still, there is a class of secondary paralyses that are in no way to be confounded with such effects as these: for instance, it occasionally happens, almost in the very first onset of severe sciatic pain, that the limb hangs absolutely helpless; and in one such case lately, being struck with the completeness of the loss of power, I tested the Faradic irritability by directing a sharp current on comparatively exposed portions of the painful nerve (e. g., in the popliteal space, and behind the head of the fibula), and elicited only the most feeble contractions, entirely unlike what the same current evoked in the opposite limb. I regret that I have as yet found it impossible to carry out a regular inquiry as to the sensibility to the different currents of motor nerves which are centrally connected with neuralgic sensory nerves.
Muscular viscera which are composed of unstriped fibre, like the intestines, or of a mixture of striped and unstriped, like the heart, are probably very liable to a secondary paralytic influence from certain special neuralgiæ. It is ascertained that the pain of a certain degree of severity in the branches of the fifth may absolutely stop the heart's action for a moment – an effect which is succeeded, usually, by violent and disorderly pulsations. I have myself once known the operation of "pivoting" a tooth, which gave frightful pain, cause instantaneous and most alarming arrest of the heart's motion, which for a minute or two seemed as if it were going to be fatal. But the variety of visceral paralysis which is probably far the most frequent is secondary paralysis of the bladder, from neuralgia in one or other of the pelvic organs, or of the external genitalia; and next to this comes paralytic distension of the cæcum, colon, or rectum, secondary to various abdominal and pelvic neuralgic affections. In one instance of acute ovarian neuralgia that I saw, the paralytic distention of the colon was by far the most remarkable circumstance, so enormously was it developed; and for some days after the neuralgia had ceased, and when the flatulence had nearly disappeared, the intestine remained absolutely torpid.
4. Convulsive actions of muscles, as every one knows, are very common complications of neuralgia. In trigeminal neuralgias these may be observed (according to the division or divisions of the nerve that are affected) in the proper muscles of the eye, or in those supplied by the fourth and sixth nerves, or (perhaps only when two or three divisions of the fifth are neuralgic at once) by the portio dura. It is curious, however, that those formidable spasmodic affections of the face which belong to the same order as torticollis and writer's cramp, are not frequently, if ever, directly associated with trigeminal neuralgia. The only connection between them seems to be that these peculiar spasmodic affections are only developed in highly-neurotic families, some of whose members are almost sure to be found suffering from some form of regular neuralgia. In severe sciatica it has several times happened to me to see convulsive action of the flexors, bending the leg spasmodically upon the thigh. And in a very large proportion of all neuralgias, wherever situated, attentive observation of the patient during the paroxysms will detect the existence of local twitching or local spasm of muscles, though these may be slight in degree.
Among the convulsive affections must be reckoned convulsive movements and tonic spasms of various portions of the alimentary canal. Vomiting is a common example of this; in migraine it is the regular and necessary climax of attacks which last with severity for a certain time; indeed, any severe attack of neuralgia involving the ophthalmic division of the fifth may excite vomiting. Convulsive action of the pharyngeal muscles, as a complication of pharyngeal or laryngeal neuralgia, occasionally occurs to such an extent as to render deglutition difficult or impossible for the time. And I have seen what I do not doubt to have been a spasmodic condition of the rectum induced by peri-uterine neuralgia. The genito-urinary organs are also not unfrequently affected spasmodically in consequence of a neuralgic affection either peri-uterine or pudendal. I have seen spasmodic stricture of the male urethra thus produced, and likewise vaginal spasm.
5. Impairments of sensation, both common and special, are very frequent attendants of neuralgia. As regards the special sensations, we may first mention that of touch; this is almost constantly impaired, immediately before, during, and some little time after a neuralgic paroxysm, in the skin supplied by the painful nerves. I was first led to make this observation by my own experience; the skin all round the inner angle of my right eye is permanently less sensitive to distinctive impressions than that of the opposite side, and this impairment is always decidedly greater, and spreads over a larger surface, before, during, and for some time after, the attacks of pain. More extended observation has convinced me that a certain amount of bluntness of distinctive skin-sensation accompanies nearly every neuralgia. As regards the sense of taste, I have found this decidedly perverted, at the time of an attack, even in my own case, although the neuralgia never extends into the third branch of the nerve. It is interesting to notice, in connection with this, that the epithelium of my tongue has been seen, on one occasion, to be exaggerated on the side of the neuralgic affection, showing a probability that there is perturbed function, at any rate of certain fibres, of the third division. But I have seen much more decided alteration, indeed temporary entire abeyance of the power to distinguish between the tastes of different substances, with the affected side of the tongue, in a case of severe epileptiform tic in which the third division was strongly affected with neuralgia; and Notta records a similar instance. As regards vision, besides minor perversions and disturbances, I have observed more or less complete amaurosis in several instances of ophthalmic neuralgia; in one case it was absolute, and lasted, with but slight improvement in the intervals between the paroxysms, for nearly a month, but disappeared entirely, though somewhat gradually, after the final cessation of the neuralgia. As regards hearing, I have noticed serious impairment only in five cases, all of them of a severe type of trigeminal neuralgia, involving all three divisions of the nerve. Smell, I have never observed to be more than doubtfully impaired, except in one case (vide Chapter III), where it was completely destroyed.
Common sensation was reported by Notta as affected in only three cases out of a hundred and twenty-eight; but my own experience has afforded a much larger proportion of instances in trigeminal neuralgia. Indeed, in all situations neuralgia appears to me to involve this effect, in the larger number of instances, in the early stages; later, it is supplanted in part by great tenderness on pressure in the well known points douloureux, and sometimes the tenderness becomes diffused over a considerable surface. I agree with Eulenburg in thinking that anæsthesia is more frequent in sciatica than in other neuralgias.
6. Secretion is often very notably affected in neuralgia; the phenomena are necessarily more easily observed in connection with affections of the trigeminal than of other nerves. In the great majority of cases the affection is in the direction of increase; at least, the watery elements of secretion are often poured out in profusion. Thus, profuse lachrymation is exceedingly common in ophthalmic neuralgia; in a large number of cases there is also copious thin nasal flux on the affected side; sometimes, however, the secretion, though copious, is semi-purulent, or bloody. Increased salivation has been noticed, by a large number of observers, in neuralgia involving the lower division of the fifth. In a smaller number of instances, the secondary effect on secretion is precisely opposite; thus both Notta and myself have observed complete dryness on the nostril on the affected side in ophthalmic neuralgia.
I might expand this chapter on the complications of neuralgia to a very much greater length; but, as regards the clinical history of these affections, it is perhaps better not to occupy more time and space. It will, however, be necessary to return to the consideration of the subject in connection with Pathology.
CHAPTER III.
PATHOLOGY AND ETIOLOGY OF NEURALGIA
The pathology and the etiology of neuralgia cannot be considered apart; they must be discussed together at every step. I do not mean to say that neuralgia is singular among diseases in this respect; it seems to me merely a case in which the intrinsic defects of the conventional system of separating the "causes" of disease from its pathology happen to be more glaring and more easily demonstrable than usual.
Neuralgia possesses no "pathology," if by that word we intend to signify the knowledge of definite anatomical changes always associated with the disease, in a manner that we can exhibit or exactly describe. It also possesses no demonstrable causes, if we employ the word "causes" in the old metaphysical sense. And yet I am very far from admitting, what seems to be so generally taken for granted, that we know less about the seat, the nature, and the conditions of neuralgia than of other diseases. On the contrary, I believe, with all deference to the supporters of the ordinary opinion, that we know more about neuralgia, in all these respects, than we do about pneumonia, only our knowledge is not of the superficial and obvious kind, but requires the aid of reason and reflection to develop and turn it to account. It has long been a matter of surprise to me, that even able writers have been content to talk about this disease (as, indeed, they have been content to speak of many nervous diseases) with an inexplicable looseness of phraseology. They speak of its "protean" forms; whereas, in my humble judgment, its forms are by no means specially numerous. They insist on the mysterious and unintelligible manner of its outbreaks, remissions and departure; but I shall try to show that, although, in the investigation of neuralgia, we are continually stopped in particular lines of inquiry by what seems to be ultimate facts, susceptible of no further immediate solution, the channels of information open to us are so unusually numerous as to enable us to accumulate a mass of information which, upon further reflection, will be found to furnish the materials of a synthesis of the disease singularly clear and effective for every practical purpose of the physician. In one important particular I especially hope to convince the reader that a large proportion of the mystification as to the pathology of neuralgia is gratuitous, and the result of great carelessness in estimating the comparative value of different facts. I hope to show clearly that, as regards both the seat of what must be the essential part of the morbid process, and the general nature of the process itself, we possess very definite information indeed. I expect, in short, to convince most readers that the essential seat of every true neuralgia is the posterior root of the spinal nerve in which the pain is felt, and that the essential condition of the tissue of that nerve-root is atrophy, which is usually non-inflammatory in origin. This doctrine seems, at first sight, presumptuous,16 in the confessed absence or extreme scarcity of dissections which even bear at all upon the question. But one source of the extraordinary interest which the pathology of neuralgia has long possessed for me resides in this very fact, that I am convinced we can demonstrate the above apparently difficult theorem by means of pathological observations on the living subject, taken in conjunction with physiological experiments, and with only the aid of a very few isolated facts of positive morbid anatomy. I need hardly say that I am none the less anxious for that further assurance which we shall one day, perhaps, obtain by means of greatly-improved processes for microscopic detection of minute changes in nerve-centres; but, looking to the necessary rarity of opportunities for post-mortem examinations of the nervous system in any but the most advanced stages of neuralgias, it will hardly be disputed that, if I am right in my main position, we are singularly fortunate to be so unusually independent of the need for this source of information.
1. The first fact which strikes me as of decided importance is the position of neuralgia as an hereditary neurosis; and this character of the disease is so pregnant with significance, that I shall take some considerable pains to put the fact beyond doubt in the reader's mind.
There are two series of facts which support the theory of the inheritance of the neuralgic tendency: (a) instances in which the parent of the sufferer had also been affected with the disease; and (b) instances in which the family history of the patient being traced out more at large it appeared that, among the members of two or more generations, while one, two, or more individuals had been actually neuralgic, other members had suffered from other serious neuroses (such as insanity, epilepsy, paralysis, chorea, and the tendency to uncontrollable alcoholic excesses), and, in many instances, that this neurotic disposition was complicated with a tendency to phthisis.
(a) The question of the direct transmission of neuralgia itself from the parent seems the easiest of decision, though even this cannot always be satisfactorily cleared up by the hospital patients, among whom one collects the largest part of one's clinical materials. However, I have been at the pains of investigating a hundred cases of all kinds of neuralgia, seen in hospital and private practice, with the following results: twenty-four gave distinct evidence that one or other parent had suffered from some variety of neuralgia; fifty-eight gave a distinctly negative answer; and eighteen would not undertake to give any answer at all. Among the twenty-four affirmatives are inserted none in which the history of the parent's affection did not clearly specify the liability to localized pain, of intermitting type, but recurring always in the same situation during the same illness. In three of these twenty-four instances, the patient stated that both parents had suffered from such attacks, and, in one of these, it appeared that the grandfather had likewise suffered.
(b) The question of the tendency of a family, during two or more generations, to severe neuroses of more or less varying kinds, including neuralgia, is difficult to work out perfectly, though in a large number of instances we may get enough information to be very useful. I have spent much time and trouble in endeavoring to collect such information; but there are two main difficulties in connection with all such attempts. From hospital patients you frequently can get no reliable information whatever respecting any members of the family farther back than the immediate parents; and, even respecting uncles and aunts and first cousins, it is often impossible to learn any thing. And when you get to a higher class of society, especially when you approach the highest, although the information may exist, it may be withheld, or you may be purposely mystified. One would doubt beforehand, under these circumstances of difficulty, whether it would be possible to obtain affirmative evidence of the neurotic temperament of the families of neuralgic patients in general; but, in truth, the evidence is so overwhelming in amount, that more than enough can be obtained for our purpose. I shall give, first, the results of one special inquiry which, by the kindness of a patient, I have been able to carry out with more than usual completeness; it relates to the medical genealogy of a sufferer from sciatica; the account is fairly complete for four generations. The great-grandfather was a man of splendid physique (an only son), who lived very freely, but died an old man. His children were three sons, one of whom (though strictly temperate) was a man of eccentric and somewhat violent temper, and suffered from a spasmodic facial affection. This one, the grandfather of my patient, married a lady who died of phthisis, and among the ten children she bore him, two sons died of phthisis, two sons became chronically insane, one son died, probably of mesenteric tubercular disease (aged fifty-six), two sons are still alive at very advanced ages, and have always been perfectly healthy and strong; one daughter died in middle age, it is not certain from what cause; one daughter lived healthily to the age of eighty, and then was attacked by facial erysipelas, followed by violent and intractable epileptiform tic, which clung to her for the remaining four years of her life; and the remaining daughter, an occasional sufferer from migraine, died at the age of sixty-seven, almost accidentally, from exhausting summer diarrhœa. The fourth generation, in this branch of the family, consisted of thirty-one individuals; of whom seven have died of phthisis, or scrofulous disease; one from accidental violence, one from rheumatic fever, one from scarlet fever; and among the surviving twenty-two one has been insane, but recovered; two are decided neuralgics; one is occasionally migraineuse, and once had a smart attack of facial erysipelas, corneitis, and iritis, as the climax to a severe neuralgic attack; one has been a sufferer from chorea; one has become phthisical; one developed strumous disease, but has fairly recovered from it. The remaining fifteen enjoy good health, but are distinguished, almost without exception, by a markedly neurotic temperament, indicated by an anxious tendency of mind, quickness of perception, æsthetic taste, disposition to alternations of impulse and procrastination. Of the young fifth generation growing up, there have been twenty-five children, of whom only one has died (from fever), the rest are apparently healthy (most of them specially so); but, as few have yet reached the age for the development either of phthisis or of neurotic diseases, the future of this generation can only be guessed at. [It is unnecessary to trace the other descendants of the second generation, but I may state that their medical history, also, strongly supports the theory of inheritance of the neurotic tendency, and of the influence of an imported element of phthisis in aggravating the latter.] I suspect that, as regards the young children now growing up, everything will depend on the care with which they are fed, and the kind of moral influences brought to bear on them, two subjects which will be fully dwelt on in the chapter on Treatment.
Of less perfect inquiries on the subject of neurotic disposition inherited by neuralgic patients, I have made a great number, though I regret to say that I have not attempted the task in the whole number of those from whom I inquired as to direct inheritance of neuralgia from their parents. However, in eighty-three cases this was done with all possible care, and any deficiency of completeness in the results is not my fault. I shall take first those that were private patients, twenty-two in number, respecting whom, I may say, that the evidence is of the best, as far as it goes, since I was better able to discriminate as to the worth of statements, than in dealing with hospital patients, and have rejected every case in which the informant did not seem intelligent enough, or otherwise to have the means, to give a thoroughly reliable account.

No one, I think, can look down the above list and fail to be struck with the great preponderance of cases in which the general neurotic temperament plainly existed in the patients' families; and let me add that, in not a few of these cases, the neuralgia in the individual under observation might have been easily set down as dependent merely upon peripheral irritation, which, indeed, plainly did act as a concurrent cause.
Fortunately, however, I am not dependent upon my own evidence alone, for the proofs of the proposition that neuralgia is eminently a development of hereditary neuroses. The great French alienists, Morel and Moreau of Tours, some years ago laid the foundations of the doctrine of hereditary neurosis. They enforced this chiefly with reference to the manner in which insanity is transmitted through a chain of variously-neurotic members of a family stock; and Moreau laid special stress on the deeply interesting connection of the phthisical with the neurotic tendency. Since then various observers have insisted on the same thing. Of late, Dr. Maudsley has worked out this subject with great ability, in his work "On the Physiology and Pathology of Mind," and in his recent "Gulstonian Lectures;" and Dr. Blandford dwells on it with emphasis in his interesting "Lectures on Insanity." [Dr. Blandford does not, however, admit that the phthisical diathesis has any such close and causal relation with neuroses as has been imagined by some recent pathologists; and, on the other hand, he points out that phthisis in neurotic subjects, e. g., the insane, must, in a large measure, be considered the product of the accidentally unhealthy circumstances in which they pass their lives. In the latter opinion I entirely agree.] Indeed, it may be taken as a recognized fact, among the more advanced students of nervous diseases, that hereditary neurosis is an important antecedent of neuralgia, in at least a very large number of instances. I shall conclude this part of the argument by stating the general results of my inquiries respecting sixty-one hospital patients. Of these cases, twenty-two were migraine, or some other affection of the ophthalmic division of the fifth nerve; seven were sciatica; two were epileptiform facial tic; ten were neuralgias affecting chiefly the second and third divisions of the fifth nerve; three were intercostal neuralgias pure; one was intercostal neuralgia plus anginoid pain; seven were intercostal neuralgias with zoster; three were brachial neuralgias; and five were abdominal neuralgias (hepatic, gastric, mesenteric, etc.) Of eighty-three hospital and private patients [It must be understood that the respective numbers do not indicate with any accuracy the relative frequency of the different neuralgias as seen in my practice. (Sciatica, e. g., was proportionally more frequent.) They represent but a small part of the neuralgic patients whom I have seen during fourteen years of dispensary, hospital, and private practice, and they were selected for inquiry merely because I happened to be able to give the time for the necessary questions. Every one who knows out-patient practice will understand how seldom this happened.] I obtained evidence of the presence, among blood-relations, of the following diseases: Epilepsy, fourteen cases (eight were examples of migraine); hemiplegia or paraplegia, nine cases; insanity, twelve cases; drunken habits, fourteen cases; "consumption," eighteen cases; "St. Vitus's dance," four cases. I am well aware that these figures must be taken with caution, and that considerable doubt must rest on the accuracy of some of these details, more especially with regard to "epilepsy," as it was impossible, with the greatest care, to be sure that this was not given, by mistake, for hysteria in some cases; and the same may apply to the statement that relations had suffered from "consumption." The facts are given for what they are worth, and with the express reservation that their total reliability is far less than that of the accounts obtained respecting private patients belonging to the more educated classes. But, in one respect, viz., as regards drunken habits, it is possible that a truer estimate is gained from the statements of hospital patients than from those of private patients, who would usually be more prone to reticence on such a topic.
From the varied considerations which have now been adduced, the reader, unless I altogether miscalculate the value of the facts, will probably have arrived at the following conclusions: (1) That the assumption of a positive material centric change as the essential morbid event in neuralgia is almost forced upon us; (2) that, whereas the morbid process, if centric, is a priori infinitely more likely to be seated in the posterior root of the painful nerve, or the gray matter immediately connected with it, than anywhere else; so, again, the assumption of this locality will explain, as no other theory could explain, the singular variety of complications (all of them nearly always unilateral, and on the same side as the pain) which are apt to group themselves around a neuralgia; and some of which are very seldom absent in neuralgia of any considerable severity. To this we may certainly add that it is extremely probable that the vast majority of neuralgic patients inherit the tendency to this localized centric change; in support of this we may finally mention two considerations derived from the sex and the ages most favorable to neuralgia. Eulenburg saw a hundred and six cases of neuralgia of all kinds, of which seventy-six were in women and only thirty in men; my own experience is very similar; namely, sixty-eight women and thirty-two men out of a hundred hospital and private patients. The strong connection between the hysteric and the neuralgic temperament in women, and the great preponderance of women among neuralgics, strengthen in no small degree the probability of inherent tendencies to unstable equilibrium as a very common predisposing factor in neuralgia. And, on the subject of age, I need only recall what I have said so strongly about the coincidence of neuralgia with particular epochs in life, as affording evidence of the most powerful kind that neuralgics are, save in exceptional instances, persons with congenitally weak spots in the nervous centres, which break down into degeneration, temporary or permanent, under the strains imposed by one or other of the physiological crises of the organism, or the special physical or psychical circumstances which surround the patient's life.
Having thus decidedly expressed my belief in the essential material participation of the nerve-centre in neuralgia, it remains for me to discuss two points: first, as to the character of the material change in the nerve-root, and next, as to the extent to which mere peripheral influence, without special inherited tendencies, may suffice to set this process going.
The morbid change in the nerve-centre is probably, in the vast majority of cases, an interstitial atrophy, tending either to recovery, or to the gradual establishment of gray degeneration, or yellow atrophy, of considerable portions of the whole of the posterior root, and the commencement of the sensory trunk as far as the ganglion.
It is probable, however, that in a certain number of cases, the atrophic stage may be preceded by a process of genuine inflammation, and that this inflammation is centripetally produced in consequence of inflammations of peripheral portions of the nerve. The considerations which make this probable are chiefly derived from the analysis of cases in which a more or less chronic, but severe, visceral disorder has been followed by so-called reflex paralysis, but in which neuralgic phenomena, have been conspicuous. In reference to this subject I recommend to the reader's attention the very interesting paper on "Reflex Paralyses" by Prof. Leyden, of Konigsberg.28 He is immediately commenting upon a case in which dysenteric affection of the bowel were followed by the symptoms of myelitis, attended with febrile exacerbations, and also with severe pains in the region of the sacrum, in the course of the dorsal intercostal nerves of the right side, and in the knees, and semi-paralytic weakness of the lower extremities, and with pains between the shoulder-blades and the left arm. Leyden discusses the doctrine of reflex paralyses in general, starting from the cases of urinary paraplegia brought forward by Stanley, in 1835, and tracing the growth of opinion through the phases represented by Graves, Henoch, and Romberg, by Valentine and Hasse, then by Pfuger, and other professors of the inhibitory doctrine; by Brown-Sequard (in his well-known, and now very generally discredited, theory of spasm of the vessels in the nervous centres), by Jaccoud in the "Erschopfung" (exhaustion) theory, down to the more careful and reliable researches of Levisson on the temporary reflected paralyses induced by experimental squeezing of the kidney or uterus of animals; and then gives the history of the more recent doctrine of a positive material change in the cord centripetally introduced. Gull29 (1856) may be said to have inaugurated the new doctrine of a morbid process transmitted along the pelvic nerves to the cord, and causing material changes there. Remak,30 on the other hand, suggested a material change operating in the opposite direction; a neuritis descendens, starting in the very nerves (within the pelvis) which showed the paralysis in the extremities. The symptoms are supposed by him to be distinctive, inasmuch as there is both violent pain in the nerves of the soles of the feet, and also tenderness of the same. On the other hand, Remak said that myelitis, with neuritis, might be the origin of paraplegia and simultaneous palsy of bladder and rectum. The theory of neuritis descendens was supported by Kussmaul,31 in the record of a case where disease of the bladder was complicated with pelvic inflammation, atheromatous degeneration of the arteries, and consequent fatty degeneration of the sciatic nerves, causing direct paraplegia. We return to the centripetal theory of urinary paralysis with Leyden's own cases, published in 1865; of three patients with urinary paraplegia, two died, and the existence of a secondary (centripetal) myelitis seems to have been established, and by all analogy it must have existed in the third case, which recovered. The only puzzle and doubt that ensued was caused by the fact that there was an absence of neuritis in the different nerves themselves; though it seemed plain that the starting point of the myelitis was at the entrance of these nerves into the cord. This mystery seemed to be cleared up by the important experiments of Tiesler, ("Ueber Neuritis" Konigsberg, 1860) a pupil of Leyden's. This observer excited local traumatic inflammation in the sciatic nerve of rabbits and dogs; the rabbit became paraplegic and died three days afterward. At the site of the artificial irritation there was a localized formation of pus, and there was a second similar formation within the vertebral canal at the point where the posterior roots of the sciatic enter the cord; but there was no neuritis of the intervening portion of the nerve.
Upon this and similar evidence is based the modern doctrine of a neuritis migrans, with centripetal tendencies, upon which it is supposed that a very large proportion, at least, of the urinary, dysenteric, and uterine paraplegias, miscalled "reflex," depend; and it is clear that the application of the word "reflex" in such a case is a grave abuse, tending to produce such confusion of thought and error in practice. In relation to the subject of our own inquiry – neuralgia – it is obviously of the highest consequence to investigate the question whether peripheral irritations, analogous to those which produce urinary paraplegia, are at all frequently the cause of the changes in the posterior roots which produce true neuralgia; for of course an inflammation may be the beginning of an atrophy which may presently exhibit no distinction whatever from one of which the origin was altogether non-inflammatory. I think that there is strong reason for thinking that this is not at all frequently the case. In the first place, all the evidence that exists respecting these centripetal inflammations of the cord is opposed to the idea that, save in the rarest instances, the inflammatory process limits itself to one small segment of the cord. Secondly, the description of the pains that have usually accompanied such inflammations of the cord is considerably different from the strictly localized, frankly intermittent character of a true neuralgia; in fact, all we know of the history of myelitis (except when complicated with a large amount of meningitis) forbids us to suppose that severe pain would be an immediate symptom. But, thirdly, a far more important objection to the theory of an origin in localized centripetal myelitis, the result of a neuritis migrans, is the rarity of motor paralysis as an early symptom, instead of which we ought to find a very distinct history of decided paralysis (much more decided than those secondary paralyses which actually do occur in some neuralgias) of the muscles supplied by the anterior roots of the painful nerve, in every case in which such a peripheral origin could be assumed. Again, the totally feverless commencement of neuralgias, a character which is maintained throughout the progress of the milder cases, is entirely opposed to the idea of a direct connection between myelitis and neuralgia. The superficial appearance of pyrexia is sometimes given by a local vaso-motor paralysis, which makes the neuralgic part, after a long bout of pain, hot and red; but of general pyrexia there is nothing.
Taking every thing into consideration, one is inclined to say that there is a probability that in a very limited number of cases peripheral irritation does cause actual limited myelitis, which escapes recognition at the time, but which issues in an atrophy, the subjective expression of which is actual neuralgic pain. We may well ask ourselves, also, whether there is not some likelihood that a peripheral irritation, which stops short of producing an actual neuritis migrans capable of centripetally exciting a myelitis, may not, by a lower degree of centripetal irritation, give a bias toward certain forms of non-inflammatory atrophy in cells of posterior nerve-roots which are congenitally of weak organization. I am inclined to believe strongly that this does occur. For example, I should explain thus the majority of the peripheral cases of ciliary neuralgia, migraine, etc., that we meet with in poor young needle-women, especially the hypermetropic, who, at an age when they can ill afford the strain, work so constantly and strenuously at an occupation which fearfully taxes the eye.
I would also go farther, and express the opinion that peripheral influences of an extremely powerful and continuous kind, where they occur with one of those critical periods of life at which the central nervous system is relatively weak and unstable, can occasionally set going a non-inflammatory centric atrophy which may localize itself in those nerves upon whose centres the morbific peripheral influence is perpetually pouring in. Even such influences as the psychical and emotional, be it remembered, must be considered peripheral – that is, they are external to the seat and centre of the neuralgia. And there are probably few practitioners of large experience who have not seen a patient or two in whom the concurrence of some unfortunate psychical with some other noxious peripheral influence, the whole taking place at some critical period of life (especially in the years between puberty and marriage), seems to have totally deranged the general balance of nervous forces, and induced morbid susceptibilities and morbid tendencies to some particular neurosis. It is a comparatively frequent thing, for example, to see an unsocial solitary life (leading to the habit of masturbation), joined with the bad influence of an unhealthy ambition, prompting to premature and false work in literature and art. The bad peripheral influence of constant fatigue of the eyes in study may so completely modify a young man's constitution as to make a wreck of him in a very few years, changing him from the state of habitual and conscious health to that of chronic neurosis of one sort or another. And, though it is doubtless on persons with congenital tendencies to nervous diseases that such a combination of bad influences produces its most serious effects, yet there unquestionably are a few persons in whom they appear to entirely generate the neurotic constitution. I have already touched upon the part that misdirected psychical influences, especially religious and other forms of emotional excitement, may play in this unfortunate perversion of the natural and healthy nervous functions, more especially in youth; and need only add, here, that perhaps the most fatal combination of all the bad influences is the melancholy union of highly-strained religious sentiment with peripheral sexual irritation, which is, unfortunately, a too common phenomenon under certain systems of education. The most frequent neurotic consequences of the class of influences which have now been referred to are probably neuralgia – in the form either of migraine, of nervous angina, or of sciatica – or else asthma.
But, if the combination of several such centripetal influences may generate the neurosis unaided, even a single one of them operating powerfully for a long period may produce most serious consequences in those who are hereditarily predisposed. The influence of prolonged fatigue of the eyesight, independently of any special intellectual or emotional strain, was strongly illustrated in my own case about three years ago. I was then engaged upon a piece of scientific writing which demanded no great intellectual effort, but was being done against time, and by working, night after night, many hours by gas-light. My neuralgic (trigeminal) attacks came on with great severity, accompanied by vertiginous sensations of so alarming a kind as to make me fear the invasion of some serious brain-mischief. I broke off all work, and went to the sea-side, but was greatly disappointed to find, for the first few days, that the symptoms were not in the least mitigated. The mystery was soon explained. The weather had been such as to confine me a good deal to the house, and, thinking it would do no harm, I amused myself with reading newspapers and novels. At last I suspected that the use of my eyes in reading was altogether mischievous; I desisted from reading any thing, and in forty-eight hours every symptom had vanished.
Among peripheral influences of a more mechanical kind there is one cause of neuralgia, the force of which has been variously estimated, but which some authors rate as very important, viz.: the influence of the pressure, and especially of the varying pressure, of blood-vessels, or other hollow viscera, upon the trunks of the nerves. We must set aside one such action which is undoubtedly very powerful, as essentially differing from the others; I mean the pressure of dilated blood-vessels, especially aneurisms, when this happens to be exerted upon the ganglion of the sensory trunk. Here there can be no doubt of the mischief; for the pressure, if at all severe, gradually destroys the life of the ganglion, upon which, as was proved by Waller, the nutrition of the posterior nerve-root hangs with very intimate dependence, and the pulsations of the vessel seem greatly to aggravate both the irritation and the centripetal tendency to atrophy. In short, it is plain that such lesion of a ganglion may be the whole and sufficient cause of a neuralgia of the most desperate and incurable kind. It is another matter when we are asked to believe that the mere varying pressure of intestines, in different states of fullness, or plexuses of pelvic veins liable to temporary congestions, can so affect the sciatic nerves as to set up neuralgia. Considering the extreme frequency of cases in which such momenta must be partially coming into operation, especially in women – a frequency altogether out of proportion to that of sciatica – I cannot admit the probability that this influence is more than an occasional and very secondary factor, and that only in cases where the disposition to neuralgia is uncommonly strong.
A sufficiently complete explanation of my theory as to the pathology and etiology of neuralgia has now been given, although the subject might be elaborated at far greater length; and I hope it will be apparent to the reader that the view now advocated is at once important, and also vouched for by strong evidence. I claim for it that the whole argument shall be taken together, for it is a case of cumulative proof; every link must be weighed and tested, before the remarkable strength of the chain can be felt. And it may fairly be said that, if the proof of a definite kind of material change in a definite organ, as the essential factor in neuralgia, has been established upon reasonable grounds, an important step has been taken toward removing a serious opprobrium and difficulty in practical medicine. Although the true neuralgias are not among the most frequent of human diseases, they form a class of enormous practical importance, for they are sufficiently common to be sure to occur in considerable numbers in the practice of every medical man, and, both from the suffering which they inflict, and the rebelliousness which they often show to treatment, they are among the gravest sources of anxiety which the practitioner is likely to encounter. There are probably few disorders which so often occasion mortification and loss of professional credit to the physician. The helplessness which men, who do not enjoy special opportunities of seeing those diseases with frequency, so often show in dealing with them, is largely caused by the extreme timidity and vagueness with which the standard treatises on medicine deal with the question of their pathology; and a very unfair advantage has thus been given to the specialists, who, by the mere force of opportunity, and continual blind "pegging away" in an entirely empiric manner, have acquired a certain rude skill in the treatment of these maladies which enables them to outshine practitioners who often have far more in them of the veritable homme instruit as regards general scientific education and habits of mind. It will be evident, as a mere abstract proposition, that the enunciation of a reasonable pathology of the disease, and the sweeping away of a mass of unmeaning phrases about "mysterious functional affections" and the like, must be a distinct gain to practitioners of plain common-sense and good general knowledge, to whom neuralgia is merely one of a vast number of different diseases among which their attention and study are divided. And I hope that, in the further remarks on Diagnosis, Prognosis, and Treatment, yet to be made, the value of clear pathological ideas of disease will be brought more practically and clearly into view. [The reader will find, at the end of Part I. of this volume, a note which contains a brief discussion on the "Erschopfung" theory of Jaccoud, and the doctrines of Dr. Handfield Jones respecting inhibition, with which I thought it best not to encumber the text of the present chapter.]
CHAPTER IV.
DIAGNOSIS AND PROGNOSIS OF NEURALGIA
Diagnosis.– This subject is much simplified and shortened, in regard to our present purpose, by the plan of the present work, which, by separately describing (in Part II.) the other disorders which resemble neuralgia, and are liable to be confounded with it, avoids the necessity for stating here the negative diagnosis of neuralgia itself. We are only concerned here to give a clear picture of the positive signs which it is necessary to verify before we can suppose disease to be neuralgia. The special modes of searching for these are interesting, and in some respects peculiar;
(1) The first and most essential characteristic of a true neuralgia is, that the pain is invariably either frankly intermittent, or at least fluctuates greatly in severity, without any sufficient and recognizable cause for these changes.
(2) The severity of the pain is altogether out of proportion to the general constitutional disturbance.
(3) True neuralgic pain is limited with more or less distinctness to a branch or branches of particular nerves; in the immense majority of cases it is unilateral, but when bilateral it is nearly always symmetrical as to the main nerve affected, though a larger number of peripheral branches may be more painful on one side than on the other.
(4) The pains are invariably aggravated by fatigue or other depressing physical or psychical agencies.
The above are characteristics which every genuine neuralgia possesses, even in its earliest stages; if they be not present, we must at once refer the diagnosis to one or other of the affections described in Part II. of this work.
Supposing the above symptoms to be present, we expect to find —
(5) In by far the largest number of instances that the patient has either previously been neuralgic, or liable to other neuroses, or that he comes of a family in which the neurotic disposition is well marked. Failing this, we are strongly to doubt the neuralgic character of the malady, unless we detect that there has been —
(6) A poisoning of the blood by malaria (but this very rarely causes neuralgia, save in the congenitally predisposed); or —
(7) A powerfully operating or very long-continued peripheral irritation centripetally directed upon the sensory nucleus of the painful nerve; which irritation may be (a) "functional," as where the eye has been persistently and severely over-strained and trigeminal pain results, or a sudden severe shock has been received; or, (b) coarsely material, as where inflammation, ulceration, etc., of surrounding tissues involve the periphery of the painful nerves in a perpetually morbid action, or chronic but profoundly depressing psychical influences; or —
(8) A constitutional syphilis. In this case there will either be marked syphilitic local affection of the trunk of a nerve, or if, as is more common, the syphilitic change is in the nerve-centre, there will most likely be other syphilitic centric mischiefs, leading to scattered motor or vaso-motor paralyses, characteristic modifications of special sense-functions, etc.
If the neuralgia be of some standing and a certain degree of severity, there will inevitably be found —
(9) Some of the fixed tender points of Valleix, in such situations as have been described in Chapter I.; and —
(10) Secondary affections (a) of secreting glands, or (b) vaso-motor nerves; or (c) of nutrition of tissues; or secondary localized paralyses of muscles, or localized anæsthesia of a somewhat decided though not complete kind, as described in Chapter II.; any one or any number of these various complications may be present.
I must insist that the above picture includes only the essentials for a diagnosis of neuralgia; if the painful affection will not answer to the conditions therein included, we have no right to call it a neuralgia – it belongs, for every practical purpose, to some other category of disease. Let me add one more essential characteristic, which is, that the pain begins and assumes its characteristic type before any other of the phenomena appear, with the single and partial exception of anæsthesia.
There are some special modes of diagnosis of the varieties of neuralgia, developed of late years, that require notice here; they are chiefly the result of the researches of Moriz Benedikt.
As regards the quality of the pain, Benedikt says that the curve of intensity has an intimate relation to the locus in quo of the neuralgia (i. e., whether in the periphery, trunk, or roots). An inflammatory irritation set up at the periphery of a nerve (by a joint-inflammation, for instance) produces a continuous pain; the same kind of irritation, attacking a nerve-trunk (e. g., in the bony canals), produces a paroxysmal pain; an inflammation spreading from the vertebræ to the nerve-roots or the cord-centres produces momentary lancinating pains. The latter characteristic he supposes to be especially characteristic of the centrally-produced neuralgias; and I may observe, as so far confirmatory of this idea, that this is especially the character of the pains in locomotor ataxy. There are sundry special cases to be considered, however: thus, Benedikt himself remarks that the pain set up by the pressure of a pulsating aneurism is, from the nature of things, lancinating from moment to moment. Eulenburg,32 moreover, says that Benedikt's tests of the locality of the primary mischief only hold good under the following circumstances: (1) When the irritability and the exhaustibility of the nerves are in a normal condition during the neuralgia; (2) when the irritation that calls forth the paroxysm is either identical with the original cause of the disease, or at least operates upon the same spot. The two conditions, however, do not concur. The irritability and exhaustibility may be sometimes excessive in neuralgias, sometimes normal, and perhaps, in certain cases, beneath the normal standard; by which means the form of the curve of intensity must be considerably modified. Moreover, the irritation that provokes an attack may from the periphery attack the primary seat of the disease, even when this is central, on account (says Eulenburg) of exaggerated conductivity of the nerves (his second cause33 of "hyperæsthesia"), as is, in fact, very frequently the case. He also thinks the distinction between paroxysmal and lancinating pains too indefinite to serve as a sufficiently reliable basis of diagnosis, especially considering the endless nuances of the form which the pain is apt to take. I agree with Eulenburg upon this point; and am convinced, from my own observations, that such a distinction as that between lancinating and paroxysmal pains is illusory, [I have taken some pains to investigate the character of the pains, not only in neuralgia, but in locomotor ataxy. It is true that the lancinating character predominates, on the whole, in the latter disease; but there are great differences in different individuals, and even in the same patient at various times, which plainly depend on subjective influences. Compare for instance, Dr. Headlam Greenhow's report on an ataxic patient, with a report on the same man by Dr. Buzzard and myself. ("Trans. Clin. Soc.," vol. i., 1868, pp. 152-162.)] the two kinds being frequently found alternate in the same case. The only useful distinction, in my opinion, is Benedikt's first one: he is probably right in saying that, where such an affection as an inflamed joint forms the source of peripheral irritation that immediately provokes a neuralgia, the pain is apt to be unusually continuous.
The extent to which the pain of neuralgia spreads into different termini of the same nerve has been made the basis of distinctions as to the seat of the original mischief. For example, it has been said that pain in the mental branch of the third division of the trigeminus, which does not invade the auriculo-temporal branch, can hardly depend on an irritation operating on the trunk of the inferior dental; it must be distinctly peripheral, or else it must act upon limited portions of the central origin of the fifth nerve. But the fact seems rather to be that, whether the neuralgia was excited by lesions at the periphery, in the nerve-trunk, or in the centre, it is equally possible that either a small or a large part of the peripheral expanse of the nerve may become the seat of the pain: this almost necessarily follows from the entire independence of individual fibres in nerves.
As regards the evidence afforded by the motor, vaso-motor, and trophic complications, there is this very positive diagnostic value in them – that they enable us to say, with greater assurance than we could otherwise do, that the disease is a real neuralgia. But, the only evidence that they afford as to the situation of the mischief is, that they uniformly point to the central end of a particular nerve; and accordingly I have already shown, in the chapter on Pathology, that the attentive study of these very complications furnishes us with some of the most powerful arguments upon which rests my theory that in neuralgia there is always centric mischief. What share in the production of the malady, in any given case, has been taken by the centric disease, and what if any by a peripheral irritation, the existence of these complications in no way helps us to determine; far less does it enable us to localize a peripheral lesion which may have acted as a concomitant cause; on the contrary, I believe that there is no more fertile source of erroneous judgment on this very point, than some of these complications, especially the vaso-motor and trophic. I suspect that it has happened, in hundreds of instances, that a localized congestion or inflammation, which is a mere secondary phenomenon, produced in the centrifugal manner already so fully explained, has been taken for the veritable fons et origo of the malady: hence the neuralgia has been confidently reckoned as one peripherally produced, and, what is even worse, the whole energy of treatment has been directed to a mere outlying symptom, under the idea that the primary source of mischief was being attacked.
The application of electricity as a test of the nature of a neuralgia has been employed by Benedikt,34 who lays down certain laws as the result of his researches. He says that (a) in idiopathic peripheral neuralgias the nerves are not sensitive to the current; (b) in neuralgias dependent on neuritis or hyperæmia of the nerve-sheath there is general electric tenderness of the nerve; (c) in cases where the pain has been set up by morbid processes in tissues surrounding the nerve, there is electric tenderness only at the site of these changes. I may, in general terms, express concurrence in these statements; but I must add that, as diagnostic rules they apply only to the early stages of neuralgia; for the occurrence of secondary complications may and does altogether change the condition of electric sensitiveness. It need hardly be said that the above remarks on diagnosis apply for the most part only to the superficial neuralgias, which, however, include an immense majority of the cases of neuralgias. The diagnosis of visceral neuralgias is, it need hardly be said, in most cases, a far more difficult and complicated matter. In these diseases we have often little more to guide us, in the actual symptoms, than (a) the intermittence of the pain, and (b) the absence of commensurate constitutional disturbance, especially the complete freedom from sense of illness in the intervals between the pains. We shall be obliged to rely greatly on such historical facts as the presence or absence of neurotic tendencies in the patient and his family; the possibility of his having been exposed to blood-poisoning (e. g., from malaria or chronic alcoholic excess, or extreme over-smoking); the circumstance that he has been habitually overworked, or greatly exposed to agitating psychical influences; perhaps that he has been subject to a combination of several of these morbific momenta. To say truth, the diagnosis of visceral neuralgias must, at the best of times, be a difficult and anxious matter, and we can hardly ever thoroughly satisfy ourselves until we have procured some decided results from treatment; fortunately, however, it happens tolerably often that we can do this, and sometimes in a very striking way.
Prognosis.– The prognosis of neuralgia varies exceedingly, according to the form and situation of the disease, and many other considerations. There are, of course, in the first place, certain neuralgias in which the prospect is perfectly hopeless as to cure; such are the cases in which the nerve is involved in a continuously growing tumor (especially within a rigid cavity, like the skull), or a slow but persistent ulcerative process.
Supposing, however, that the case is none of these, the very first prognostic consideration is that of age.
Of the neuralgias of youth, the majority either disappear altogether after a first attack, or recur a certain number of times during some years, the neuralgic tendency either disappearing or becoming greatly mitigated when the process of bodily consolidation is over. In another group the neuralgic tendency is never lost, but the form of the attacks changes, and there is far less spontaneity in the manner of their production. It is exceedingly common to see delicate boys and girls between puberty and the age of eighteen or twenty, attacked with typical migraine, which recurs regularly every three or four weeks for perhaps two or three years, then ceases to occur at regular periods, then loses the tendency to stomach complication; and, by the age of twenty-five or somewhat later, has left, as its only relic, a tendency to attacks of ophthalmic neuralgia, which come on when the patient is excessively fatigued, or encounters the close air of a theatre, or undergoes an unusual strain of mental excitement or anxiety, etc.; but which never come on without some such special provocation. So, again, there is a variety of sciatica which belongs mainly to the period between puberty and the twenty-fifth to thirtieth year, and which seems really to belong, pathologically, to the age of unsettled and irregular sexual function, the tendency to it usually disappearing after the patient has settled down happily in married life. Ovarian and mammary neuralgia have very commonly a similar history.
On the other extreme we find the neuralgias of the period of bodily decay: these are of very bad prognosis. A neuralgia which first develops itself after the arteries and capillaries have begun to change decidedly in the direction of atheroma is extremely likely, even if apparently cured for a time, to recur again and again, with ever-increasing severity, and to haunt the patient for the remainder of his days. It therefore becomes exceedingly important, in a prognostic point of view, to assure ourselves as soon as possible whether this arterial degeneration has decidedly commenced; and for this purpose I am in the habit of insisting to pupils on the great importance of sphygmographic examination for all neuralgic patients who have passed the middle age. Where we get the evidence which is furnished by the formation of a distinctly square-headed radial pulse-curve, even though there be no palpable cord-like rigidity of superficial arteries, we are bound to be exceedingly cautious of giving a favorable prognosis.
In women the period of involution of the sexual apparatus forms a crisis which, in regard to neuralgias, is of great prognostic importance. On the one hand, if the general vital status be good, and the arterial system fairly unimpaired, we may look to the completion of the process of involution as a probable time of deliverance from neuralgic troubles that have hitherto beset a woman; we know that she will probably suffer a temporary aggravation of her pains, but we hope to see her lose them altogether. On the other hand, if it should happen that she enters on the period of sexual involution with her general nutrition considerably impaired and her arterial system decidedly invaded by atheroma, it is only too likely that neuralgias recurring now, or attacking her for the first time, will assume the worst and least manageable type.
Of almost or quite equal importance with the question of the physiological age of the patient is that of his personal and family history with regard to the tendency to neuralgia and to other severe neuroses. Upon this subject I have dwelt so very fully in other parts of this work, that it is merely necessary here to repeat, that the balance of chances is most heavily swayed to the bad side by all evidence tending to prove congenital neurotic tendencies in the patient and vice versa.
Of prognostic hints that are to be gathered from our knowledge of the immediate causes of the attack, there are none so valuable as those which we gather from the detection of a malarial or a syphilitic factor in the production of the malady. In the former case, we hope to cure the patient either with quinine or arsenic, with almost magical certainty and rapidity; in the latter, we expect an almost equally brilliant result from iodide of potassium.
The particular nerve in which the neuralgia is seated does not so decidedly influence the prognosis, according to my experience, as is stated by some authors; nevertheless, there are differences of this kind. For instance, sciatica, though by no means so frequently a mild and trifling complaint as Eulenburg would make it to be, is certainly, on the whole, more curable than the trigeminal neuralgias taken as a group. I, however, cannot share Eulenburg's opinion as to the rarity of a central cause for sciatica, nor his consequent explanation of its more frequent curability; the latter I explain by the fact that it is possible far more completely to remove the concomitant causes in sciatica than in trigeminal neuralgia. By simply keeping a sciatic patient in the prone posture, shielded from cold and from pressure on the nerve, we have it in our power to remove nearly all peripheral sources of irritation; but in trigeminal neuralgia there are many influences, particularly psychical ones, which cannot be shut out, and which will continue to act with disastrous effect in many cases. With all this, however, we see a sufficiently large number of incurable sciaticas, on the one hand, and of severe trigeminal neuralgia cured on the other. It is only the genuine epileptiform tic, occurring in subjects whose arterial system is an advanced stage of degeneration, that stands out clearly and unmistakably pre-eminent among neuralgias for rebelliousness to treatment of every kind.
CHAPTER V.
TREATMENT OF NEURALGIA
I now approach what is really the most difficult portion of my task; for, although it would be easy enough to write copiously on the treatment of neuralgia, it is extremely difficult to keep a just medium between the opposite extremes of undue meagreness and of useless profusion of detail in the handling of this subject. There are also difficulties connected with the present uncertain and transitional state of opinion, even among high authorities, as to the value of particular remedies, and even of large groups of remedial agents, altogether there has been more hesitation in my mind as to this part of the present work than about any other, and the present chapter has been rewritten more than once. I mention this only to account for what there may very likely be found in it – an imperfect literary style such as too commonly marks work which has been repeatedly patched and corrected. At the same time, it should be said that my hesitation does not apply to the main principles of treatment which will be recommended below; it proceeds rather from the fear of seeming to ignore from carelessness modes of treatment which are still much used, but which I have really rejected, because, after full trial, they appeared to me valueless. Space is, after all, limited, and a complete account of all the remedies for neuralgia in vogue, in English and Continental clinics, would of itself fill a large volume.
The treatment of neuralgia may be divided into four branches: (1) Constitutional remedies; (2) narcotic-stimulant remedies; (3) local applications; (4) prophylaxis.
1. Constitutional treatment must be subdivided, as (a) dietetic, (b) anti-toxic, and (c) medicinal tonic.
(a) The importance of a greatly-improved diet for neuralgic patients is a matter which is more fully appreciated by the English school of medicine than by either the French or the German; it has, for instance, very much surprised me to notice the almost entire silence of Eulenburg on this topic. For my part, the opinions expressed three years ago35 on this matter have only been modified in the direction of increasing certainty; I have learned by further experience that the principle is even more extensively applicable than I had supposed.
That neuralgic patients require and are greatly benefited by a nutrition considerably richer than that which is needed by healthy persons, is a fact which corresponds with what may be observed respecting the chronic neuroses in general; and it gives me much satisfaction to point out this position of neuralgia as belonging to this large class of disorders, not merely by its pathological affinities, but by its nutritive demands. In a very excellent and suggestive paper by Dr. Blandford36 it is stated, as the result of a large experience in mental and other nervous disorders, that the greater number of chronic insane and hypochondriacal cases, as well as neuralgic patients, are remarkably benefited by what might seem at first sight almost a dangerously copious diet. Occasionally it happens that the patients discover this by the teaching of their own sensations, and the apparent excesses in eating which some epileptic and hypochondriacal persons habitually commit are looked on by many practitioners as the mere indications of a morbid bulimia which represents no real want, but only the craving of a perverted sensation which ought to be interfered with and allayed rather than encouraged. It is now many years since I began to doubt the justice of this opinion; the particular instance which called my attention to it being that of epilepsy, of which disease I saw a considerable number of cases, within a short period of time, that were distinguished by the presence of enormous appetite for food; and I finally came to the conclusion that, so far from this symptom being of evil augury, and likely to lead to mischief, it is, with certain limitations, a most fortunate occurrence. It is hardly necessary to say that over-eating, such as produces dyspepsia and distention of a torpid intestine with masses of fæces, may distinctly aggravate the convulsive tendency; but the truth is that, with a little careful direction and management of the unusual appetite, these bulimic patients can in most cases be allowed to satisfy their desires without harm of this kind following; a larger portion of food really gets applied to the nutritive needs of the body, and the nervous system unmistakably benefits thereby, the tendency to atactic disorder being visibly held in check.
That which I have thus observed in the case of epilepsy, and which Dr. Blandford more particularly affirms concerning chronic mental diseases and the large number of neuroses that hover on the verge of insanity, has been most distinctly verified in my experience of the treatment of neuralgia. It is, unfortunately, by no means a frequent occurrence that the sufferer from this malady is inclined to eat largely, but the few patients of this type that I have seen were, in my judgment, distinctly the better for it. Far more common in neuralgia is a disposition of the patient to care little for food, to become nice and dainty, and in particular to develop an aversion – partly sensational and partly the result of morbid fear about indigestion – for special articles of diet. Dr. Radcliffe pointed out the special tendency of neuralgics to neglect all kinds of fat; partly from dislike, and partly because they believe it makes them "bilious;" and I have had many occasions to observe the correctness of this observation. In fact, by the time patients have become sufficiently ill with neuralgia to apply to a consulting physician, they have already, in the great majority of cases, got to reject all fatty foods, and have cut down their total nutriment to a very sufficient standard. Young ladies suffering from migraine are especially apt to mismanage themselves, to a lamentable extent, in this direction: this is natural enough, because the stomach disorder seems to them the origin of the pain, instead of being, as it is, a mere secondary consequence of the neurosis. But it is not only the sufferers from sick-headache in whom we find this tendency to insufficient eating, especially of fat; not to mention that all severe pain usually tends to disorder appetite and make it fastidious, there is nearly always some wiseacre of a friend at hand, ready to suggest that neuralgia is something very like gout, that gout is always aggravated by good living, and, ergo, that the patient should be "extremely cautious as to diet;" the end of which is that the poor wretch becomes a half-starved valetudinarian, but, so far from his pain getting better, it steadily becomes worse. I cannot too strongly express the benefits that I have seen accrue, in the most various kinds of neuralgic cases, from persistent efforts to remedy this state of things, and to convert the patient from a valetudinarian to a hearty eater; and I wish particularly to say that this success has always been most marked when I have from the first insisted on fat forming a considerable element of the food. Cod-liver oil is the form in which I much prefer to give it, if this be possible; there can be no mistake about the relatively greater power of this than of any other fatty matter, I believe simply from its great assimilability. But the very cases in which we most urgently desire to give fat are often those in which the patient's fantastic stomach openly revolts at the idea of the oil; we must then try other fats; and we should go on trying one thing after another – butter, plain cream, Devonshire cream, even olive or cocoanut oil (though these are the poorest things of the sort we can use) – till we get the patient well into the way of taking a considerable, if possible a decidedly large, daily allowance of fat, without provoking dyspepsia. It is surprising what can be done in this way by perseverance and tact, and it is no less striking to observe the good effects of the treatment. Nothing is more singular than to see a girl, who was a peevish, fanciful, and really very suffering migraineuse, brought to a state in which she will eat spoonful after spoonful of Devonshire cream, and at the same time lose her headaches, lose her sickness, and develop the appetite of a day-laborer; and, though such very marked instances as this are uncommon, they do sometimes occur, and a minor but still important degree of improvement is very frequent.
As for the modus operandi of the fatty food, there is no certainty. Dr. Radcliffe believe it acts as a direct nutrient of the nervous centres; and I also cannot help feeling that there is some evidence in favor of this idea. But, whether this be so or not, there is another kind of action of fat that is more simple and obvious; namely, it seems to be certain that the enrichment of the diet by fat greatly assists the assimilation of food in general, and thus the patient's nutrition is altogether improved.
It is not merely, however, by increasing any one element of food that we should seek to enrich the diet of neuralgics, but rather by such a steady and persistent effort as Dr. Blandford describes, to increase the total quantity of nutriment to perhaps as much as one-third more than the patient would probably have taken in health. To those who from prejudice are incredulous of the propriety of this method, I would say, "Try it, and I venture to say your incredulity will disappear." More especially I would urge the great importance of this system in modifying the nervous status of very young, and also of aged, sufferers from neuralgia; it is the indispensable basis of a sound treatment for such patients.
This seems the proper place for such remarks as must be made upon the function of alcohol in neuralgia; for, though this agent is a true narcotic when given in large doses, it is not under that aspect that I can recommend its use in neuralgia at all. I have written so much on this subject lately, that I shall here content myself with an emphatic repetition of my protest against the use of alcoholic liquors as direct remedies for pain. They ought only to be given, in neuralgia, in such moderate doses, with the meals, as may assist primary digestion without inducing any torpor, or flushing of the face, or artificial exhilaration. I cannot too expressly reprobate the practice of encouraging neuralgics, especially women, to relieve pain and depression by the direct agency of wine or spirit; it is a system fraught with dangers of the gravest kind.
(b) The anti-toxic remedies include agents addressed to the modification of a special condition of the blood and tissues induced by the presence of morbid poisons, of which syphilis, malaria, and (more doubtfully) gout and rheumatism, are the representative examples.
Of syphilitic neuralgia the treatment may be summed up in a few words: Give iodide of potassium in doses rapidly increased up to a daily quantum of twenty to thirty grains. If this fails, give one-twelfth of a grain of bichloride of mercury thrice daily.
Of malarial neuralgia I can only speak from such a limited experience that I am by no means in a position to give an exhaustive account of the treatment. Quinine is, of course, the remedy that should first be tried; and, as the paroxysms are usually regular in their recurrence, I prefer to give the drug after the plan which is, I think, incontestably the best in ordinary ague —i. e., to administer one large dose (five to twenty grains) about an hour before the time when the attack is expected. With a few exceptions the malady, unless it had taken very deep root before we were consulted, will yield to a few doses given in this way; after the morbid sequence has been thus interrupted, it will be proper to continue the action of quinine in smaller and more frequent doses, given for three or four weeks continuously. For the comparatively rare cases in which quinine fails, the prolonged use of arsenic (Fowler's solution, five to eight minims three times a day), especially with the simultaneous employment of cod-liver oil, is to be recommended.
The part which gout may play in inducing neuralgia is, as I have already said, a far more doubtful question than the popular medical traditions assume it to be; and treatment directed to gout as a cause is an extremely uncertain affair. The direct relief of neuralgic pain by the administration of colchicum, for example, is, in my experience, a very rare occurrence, even where the gouty diathesis is unmistakably present; and, on the other hand, the depressed vitality which gouty neuralgics usually show in a marked degree, renders it very doubtful whether the relief of the pain may not be too dearly purchased at the cost of the general lowering effects of colchicum. It is probable that neuralgia occurring in gouty subjects is more safely, and equally effectually, treated upon general principles. At the same time it may be admitted that, in the subordinate function of an adjuvant to the aperients which it is sometimes advisable to give, small doses of the acetic extract of colchicum seem to possess some value.
The question of treatment addressed to a supposed rheumatic element in neuralgia will, of course, be differently judged according to the respective ideas of various practitioners as to the pathological affinities of the two diseases; and the reader already knows that I believe these affinities to be different in kind from what is generally believed. The utmost that I should concede is, that in a certain very limited number of cases the peripheral factor in neuralgia is an inflammation of the nerve-sheath, or surrounding tissues, which forms part of a chain of phenomena of local fibrous inflammations in different parts of the body. Iodide of potassium, in five or ten grain doses three times a day, is the proper treatment for such cases. I have never found alkalies do any direct good to the pain.
(c) The medicinal tonic variety of constitutional treatment is more especially represented by the use of iron and arsenic in cases where poverty of the blood seems to exist in a marked degree, and by the administration of certain tonics – quinine, phosphorus, strychnia, and zinc – which are supposed to exert a specially restorative influence upon the nervous tissues.
The use of quinine as an anti-malarial agent has been already referred to; its employment in non-malarial cases is of much more restricted scope and benefit. Experience has taught me to agree in general with the opinion of Valleix, that it is a very unreliable agent; the one marked exception to this being the case of ophthalmic neuralgias. What the reason may be I cannot in the least say, but it is a fact that quinine does benefit these neuralgias, in cases where there is no room for suspicion of malaria, with a frequency which is very much greater than in the treatment of the painful affections of any other nerve in the body. The quantity given should be about two grains three times a day.
The preparations of phosphorus which I have employed in the treatment of neuralgia are the phosphuretted oil, the hypophosphite of soda (five to ten grains three times a day), and pills of phosphorus (according to Dr. Radcliffe's recommendation) containing one-thirtieth of a grain, given twice or thrice daily. Either of the two last will do all that phosphorus can do, but its utility is not very extensive or reliable. I have found it to do most good in cases where there was a high degree of anæsthetic complication.
Preparations of zinc have, in my hands, done no particular good, although I have tried them in all manner of doses.
Strychnia, on the other hand, is a remedy which I have learned to prize much more highly during the last few years than previously. Its most decided efficacy has been shown in some of the visceralgiæ, especially gastralgia, and (to a less extent) angina pectoris. Its internal use for these complaints is best effected by giving doses of five to ten minims of tincture of nux-vomica three times a day; but a method which I have several times employed with good effect is the subcutaneous injection of very small doses of strychnia (one-eightieth to one-fiftieth of a grain) twice daily. For the superficial neuralgias, on the other hand, I generally administer one-fortieth of a grain, with ten or fifteen minims of tincture of sesquichloride of iron, by the stomach, three times a day; this is a very powerful prophylactic remedy to prevent the recurrence of the attacks when once the sequence of them has been broken through by other means.
Of iron generally, as a remedy in anæmic cases, I have only to remark that, in order to get its full benefits, it is necessary to use large doses. I give the saccharated carbonate in twenty-grain doses twice or three times a day.
But of the sesquichloride of iron I am inclined to say something more; it has seemed to me that, besides its effects on the blood, it has a marked and direct influence upon the nervous centres, which is different from anything which one observes in the action of other preparations of iron. It is certain that the action of sesquichloride of iron, in those cases of chlorosis which are distinguished by profound nervous depression, is something quite peculiar; and the effect which it produces in the anæmic neuralgias, more especially of young women, is equally remarkable. I cannot help alluding here to the striking effects which large doses of the tincture, as recommended by Dr. Reynolds, produce in acute rheumatism; the severest pain is often checked within twenty-four hours after the commencement of this treatment. Both in this disease and in neuralgia, I employ the old-fashioned tincture: if given alone it should be used in large doses (thirty or forty minims three times a day); but an excellent combination is that, already mentioned, of ten-minim doses of this tincture with one-fortieth of a grain of strychnia. There is something in the revivifying effects of this mixture that is quite peculiar. I have very lately employed it in the case of a gentleman, aged thirty-five, who was the subject of frontal neuralgia complicated with paralysis of the internal rectus, and who was decidedly anæmic, and greatly depressed and worried in mind by the consciousness of his inability to overtake professional work which had accumulated upon him. This patient improved with great rapidity, and in the course of three weeks lost, not merely his neuralgia, but also his strabismus, almost entirely; but he then got into a condition which, though not of permanent importance, was sufficiently undesirable to make me mention it here, especially as I have seen the same thing in more than one patient besides him. It is a peculiar state of restlessness during the day and sleeplessness at night, without any positive exaltation of reflex excitability such as one used to see from strychnia in the days when mischievously large doses of that drug were very commonly given, and patients used to complain of decided twitchings and startings of the limbs. It is clearly not a strychnia effect pure and simple, nor an iron effect only; it is a tertium quid compounded of the actions of both drugs.
The direct effects of arsenic in the improvement of the quality of the blood seem to me incontestable; and its use for this purpose in anæmic neuralgias is certainly something over and above its special neurotic action. No one, who has employed it much in the cases of anæmic children suffering from chorea after rheumatism, can have failed to observe its frequently striking influence upon blood-formation even long before the nervous ataxia is materially reduced. The misfortune is, however, that we possess no indications by which to judge beforehand whether we may reckon on its most favorable action in any given (non-malarious) case, with certain special exceptions. In angina pectoris it has a most direct effect, which is rarely altogether missed, and is sometimes surprising: the cases in which it succeeds best are those distinguished by anæmia, but we may well suppose, from its remarkable action upon other neuroses of the vagus, that it is something more than an action on the blood-making process which produces such powerful effects in allaying the tendency to recurrence of the paroxysms. My attention was called to its action in this disease chiefly by the remarkable case published by Philipp;37 this was a purely neurotic angina, but one of the severest type, and the influence of arsenic was very striking. Since that time I have employed it in several cases, and, after trying various forms of administration, I conclude that nothing is better than Fowler's solution, in doses of three minims (gradually increased, if the remedy be well tolerated, up to eight or ten) three times a day. Unfortunately, there are some neurotic patients who cannot bear arsenic, the irritability of their alimentary canal is such that the drug always provokes vomiting, or diarrhœa, or both; this was the case with one of my patients, in whose case I had allowed myself to hope for the very best results from arsenical treatment. But where the patient tolerates it – and usually he tolerates it extremely well – the prolonged use of arsenic seems really to root out the anginoid tendency, or at least to confine it to the more trivial and manageable manifestations. I believe that in at least three patients, I have so completely broken down a succession of cardiac neuralgic attacks as to substitute for them a mere remnant of a tendency to "tightness at the chest" after any severe bodily exertion or mental emotion. It might be a question, in cases where the stomach does not tolerate the ordinary administration of the agent, whether it would not be worth while to try the effect of subcutaneous injection (two to four minims of Fowler), or inhalation of the smoke of arsenical cigarettes. But, in truth, it is not certain that even in this case we escape the characteristic effects of the drug upon those persons who are abnormally sensitive to it.
A remarkable instance of the beneficial influence of arsenic occurred in the case of a woman, aged forty-six, the solitary example of severe angina in a female that I have ever seen. [It is by no means uncommon, however, to see the milder forms of cardiac neuralgia in women; the remarkable statistics of Forbes, quoted in Chapter I., must certainly have been taken exclusively from cases of the severest type of the disease.] This was a hospital patient, who had always suffered much from hysteria, and from childhood had been liable to hemicranic headache; she had entered on the period of "change" at the time the attacks began, but menstruation, though irregular, still continued, and, in fact, did not cease till four years later, long after the anginal attacks had been subdued. The patient had been attacked for the first time at the end of a heavy day's washing; she dropped on the ground with the sudden agony and faintness, and thought she should "never come to life again." The paroxysms returned five times within the next month, though not always so severely as on the first occasion; but the poor woman lived in a constant state of terror. On the occasion of her second visit to me, she had a most severe attack in the waiting-room at the hospital: being called to her I found her very nearly pulseless, gasping, and with the kind of complexion which is so suggestive of approaching death. She was recovered by a large dose of ether. It was a rather uncommon feature in this case that the pain was only at and around the lower end of the sternum, except that occasionally it shot along the sixth intercostal space. The employment of Fowler's solution (in doses gradually mounting to twenty-one minims daily) for six months completely eradicated the anginal tendency; the proof that it was a real therapeutic effect was given by the result of an attempt to leave the medicine off at the end of eight weeks' treatment; the patient immediately began to suffer again. When she really left off, at the end of six months' treatment, she had had no tendency to heart-pang for more than a month, and, besides this, looked quite another creature in her improved vitality and vigor. Yet the menstrual troubles went on, and the function was not finally suppressed for a long time afterward.
There are certain special considerations as to the habits of life that require a word or two. I need say nothing more to enforce the views already put forward as to the necessity of copious supplies of food. I need only refer to what I have already said about the decidedly mischievous tendency of anything like habitual excess in the use of alcohol, merely adding a special caution against such indulgence during, and particularly toward, the end of the period of sexual activity. There is one more topic upon which something must be said, namely, the extent to which sexual intercourse should be allowed. Speaking of neuralgia generally (excluding neuralgic affections of the sexual organs themselves), it may decidedly be said that the regular and moderate exercise of the function, during the natural period of sexual life, is beneficial; but that excess is always dangerous, and that the continuance of sexual intercourse, after the powers naturally begin to wane, is extremely pernicious in its tendency to revive latent tendencies to neuralgia. As regards neuralgias of the sexual organs, it is very difficult to speak positively; and yet I believe that (once the neuralgic habit broken through by other means) it is very desirable that the patient should live according to the laws of normal physiological life.
NOTE I
ADDITIONAL FACTS BEARING ON THE QUESTION OF NEUROTIC INHERITANCE
The following cases must be now added to those recorded in my list of private patients whose family history has been ascertained with reliable accuracy.
Case I. is that of a gentleman, aged forty-seven, the subject of lumbo-abdominal neuralgia: no history of nervous disease in the family; his mother, however, was of a "nervous" temperament.
Case II. – A gentleman, aged sixty-four, suffering from angina. His family nervous history is fearful. On the father's side it is not possible to get a clear account. But on the maternal side there has been a strong tendency to insanity and suicide; and in the patient's own generation one brother committed suicide from insanity, and one sister is still alive, insane. An interesting fact is, that the mother's family have shown an extraordinary proclivity to erysipelas.
Case III. – The young gentleman, whose single but extremely severe attack of angina is previously described, comes of a family in whom the tendency to neuralgia is undoubtedly very strongly inherited. His father is frequently and very severely migraineux, and in early life suffered cardiac symptoms not unlike his son's. A brother was also liable to attacks of true migraine between puberty and the age of twenty-one.
Case IV. – On the other hand, a case of angina which I saw in the country, last year, occurred in a gentleman, aged fifty, whose family presented no traceable neurotic history. But the damage inflicted upon his nervous system by various external influences was quite extraordinary. In some way or other he got some attacks of migraine at the age of fifteen or sixteen; for these he was treated with bleeding, and with a most savage antiphlogisticism generally. From that time he never got free of the neuralgic tendency. He used to have not only facial, but intercostal neuralgia; for this last he was repeatedly bled, under the idea that it was pleurisy. Added to all this he habitually did an immense deal of brain-work in his study, and for years had performed clerical duties of the most exacting and exhausting character. It is not much wonder that these combined circumstances had sufficed to generate the neurotic temperament.
NOTE II
THE INHIBITION THEORIES OF HANDFIELD JONES AND JACCOUD
In the present transitional state of opinion concerning the mode in which the phenomena are produced that are popularly known under the name of "reflex paralysis," I cannot pass without notice the doctrines of these two observers. The reader will have perceived that, as regards the secondary paralytic symptoms observed in neuralgias, I explain the phenomena mainly on the theory of a process which is central, and not peripheral, in origin. And, even where, as in some few instances, it seems possible that the starting-point was an organic affection of some viscus, we must always consider the possibility that the link between this and the neuralgia and paralyses was a neuritis migrans travelling inward to the sensory centre, and from that passing over to motor centres and thus producing paralysis; or that, without the intervention of any truly inflammatory process, the continual impressions streaming in upon the cord from the original seat of organic disease may damage the nutrition of the sensory nerve-root, producing a partial atrophy, and that this process may extend to the motor root.
It remains, however, to inquire whether the influence of powerful peripheral agencies may not, in a purely "functional" manner, disable the nerve-centres for a time, causing paralysis with or without neuralgia. The main supporters of such a doctrine are Dr. Handfield Jones46 and M. Jaccoud.47
Dr. Handfield Jones expressly rejects the theory of Brown-Sequard, as to spasm of the vessels in the nerve-centres, and we need not repeat his arguments on that head, because it seems to be generally felt that the vascular spasm theory will not account for the facts. Jones believes that the state produced in the nerve-centre by the peripheral influence is one of paresis from shock-depression, and that from the sensory centre this state can communicate itself to motor and vaso-motor centres, though commissural fibres. He does not believe in the existence of a special inhibitory portion of the nervous system: he believes that an impression may prove stimulating when it is mild, or paralyzing when it is strong; and that any afferent nerve may convey either the one influence or the other to the centres and thus produce secondary stimulus or secondary paralyses in various efferent nerves. Jones has the distinguished merit of being one of the first authors distinctly to perceive that pain must rank on the same level with paralysis: hence he sees nothing unintelligible in the communication of paralysis to a motor centre from a sensory centre that was in the state which the mind interprets as pain.
The theorie d'epuisement of Jaccoud (Erschopfungs-theoric) also denies the possibility of Brown-Sequard's idea of prolonged spasm of the vessels of the centres. It imagines that powerful peripheral excitements exhaust the irritability of the nerve, and through that of the centres, and induce a state of unimpressibility – analogous to that which exists in a nerve or nerve-centre, which is included in the circuit of a constant current. The nervous force is wasted, and, until an opportunity of repose is afforded to the centre, the faculty of impressibility cannot again revive.
I must say that of these two theories I decidedly incline to that of Handfield Jones (though I imagine that in reality the cases are extremely rare, if there be any, in which the change in the centres is really only functional and non-organic), I prefer the idea of paralyzing shock to that of exhaustion from over-excitement, from a consideration of the nature of that form of peripheral influence which has been specially mentioned by authors as competent to produce this sort of "reflex" affections, namely, intense and persistent cold. It seems to me a mere abuse of words to speak of this as an agent that could exhaust the nerve by over-stimulation; it must surely exhaust it in a much more direct manner than this, namely by the direct physical agency of withdrawing heat from the nerve, and spoiling its physical texture, pro tanto. If such an effect as that which must thus be produced on the nerve, and through it on the centre, is to be looked on as a case of over-stimulated function, then, it seems to me, there is no meaning in language, and no possibility of attaining to clear ideas on the subject of nervous influence.
NOTE III
ARSENICAL TREATMENT OF VISCERALGIÆ
Since writing the above chapter on the Treatment of Neuralgia, I have had two fresh and very striking examples, in private practice, of the power of arsenic to break the morbid chain of nervous actions in angina pectoris.
The first example was that of a medical man, aged seventy-five, in whom a neuralgia, originally malarial in origin, and of some years' duration, had fixed itself for some time in the fifth and sixth left intercostal spaces, and of late had become complicated with anginoid attacks of an unmistakable character, though not of the highest degree of severity. The case certainly seemed very unpromising, looking at the patient's age and the consequent high probability that there was much arterial degeneration. However, the use of Fowler's solution (five minims three times a day) was commenced and steadily pushed. The anginoid attacks rapidly diminished in frequency and at the end of ten days' time were entirely gone, and after one month of treatment he still had no return of them, although they had previously been of daily occurrence. It is a curious fact, whether a mere coincidence or not I cannot say, that, some few days after the anginoid attacks ceased, he began to experience somewhat severe pains, rheumatic in feeling, but unattended with heat or swelling, in the elbows, wrists, and fingers, symmetrically. This has nearly disappeared, but he is still free from angina. There is no discoverable heart-lesion in this patient.
The other case was that of a fine old man of sixty-four, who, but for some few slight attacks of gout, a few small calculi, and a troublesome prostatic affection, had always enjoyed remarkably good health, until about five months ago, when he began to notice tightness across the chest, etc., when he walked uphill. About a fortnight before he came to me, he was seized with very violent and alarming paroxysms of pain across the chest and running down both arms, extreme intermittence of pulse, and a sense of impending dissolution. The attack had recurred daily, at the same hour (6 p. m.), ever since; besides which there was an abiding sense of uneasiness in the cardiac region, and a consciousness that the least excitement or exertion would bring on the paroxysm. I put the patient on five minims of Fowler, three times a day, with directions to take ether when the paroxysms came. At the end of the first week there was already much improvement, the paroxysms having been both less frequent and less severe. At the end of a fortnight's treatment he reported that there had been nothing like a paroxysm for the last eight days, although there was still a good deal of uneasiness from time to time. The hour at which the attack was expected passed by absolutely without a trace of angina. It remains to be seen how long this improvement will last, but the altered state of things, and particularly the suddenness of the change, cannot be overlooked, and has very much struck the patient himself. It is now six weeks since he had any paroxysm.
It becomes more and more apparent that arsenic is generally applicable to neuroses of the vagus. In asthma, I have long held it to be the most powerful prophylactic tonic that we possess. It is also an excellent remedy in gastralgia; although I have rather dwelt (in the text of this work) on the action of strychnia in this disease, I would not omit my testimony to arsenic. Dr. Leared has related some exceedingly interesting cases bearing on this point. (See British Medical Journal, November 23 and 30, 1867.)
NOTE IV
INFLUENCE OF GALVANISM ON CUTANEOUS PIGMENT
Dr. Reynolds pointed out to me the exceedingly curious fact, which I have several times verified, that the constant current, in relieving facial neuralgia, not unfrequently disperses, almost instantaneously, the brown skin-pigment that has collected in the painful region; e. g., near the orbit.
NOTE V
THE ACTUAL CAUTERY
A remedy for inveterate neuralgia which of late years I had almost discarded – the actual cautery – has quite recently yielded me very good palliative results in two cases. Its omission from the text of the chapter on Treatment was an accident due to the effect of habit in making one, half unconsciously, reckon this remedy as a "counter-irritant." The longer I practise, however, the more decidedly I am convinced that the actual cautery, if properly applied, does not act as an irritant at all; and this fact was sufficiently in my mind, when writing of irritant remedies, to make me omit the cautery from that section. I should have inserted it under the heading of remedies that interrupt the conductivity of nerves, and thus give the centres temporary rest. The only useful way to apply it is, to make an iron white hot, and very lightly brush the skin over so as to make an eschar not followed by suppuration. The galvano-cautery (Stohrer's Bunsen) is the best for the purpose, but I have made the flat-iron cautery serve very well.
PART II.
DISEASES THAT RESEMBLE NEURALGIA
CHAPTER I.
MYALGIA
Of all the diseases which superficially resemble neuralgia, none are so likely to be confounded with it, on a cursory glance, as myalgia. More careful inquiry, however, furnishes, in nearly all cases, ample means for distinguishing between the two affections.
Myalgia is an exceedingly painful affection, and it is also much more common than was formerly supposed. It is to Dr. Inman that we undoubtedly owe the demonstration of the frequent occurrence of this malady, and the facility with which it may be mistaken for other, and sometimes much more serious, diseases, with very disastrous results. At the same time, I must express the opinion that this ingenious author has decidedly exaggerated the importance of this local disease at the expense of an unjust depreciation of the frequency and significance of other painful disorders which have their origin within the nervous system.
Myalgia proper includes all those affections which are severally known as "muscular rheumatism" (for the muscles generally), and "lumbago," "pleurodynia," etc. (according to locality). It is essentially pain produced in a muscle obliged to work when its structure is imperfectly nourished or impaired by disease.
The clinical history of the different varieties of myalgia absolutely requires this key for its interpretation; otherwise, the appearance of the sufferers from different kinds of myalgia is so widely dissimilar that we should be exceedingly likely to miss the important features of treatment, which must be applied to them all in common. Nothing, for instance, can be more strikingly unlike than the appearance of the pallid, stunted, under-nourishment cobbler who complains of epigastric myalgia, and that of the ruddy and muscular navvy who suffers from acute lumbago, or the similarly plethoric-looking country commercial traveller, who has been driving in his gig against wind and rain, and complains of violent aching pains in one or both shoulders; yet one and all of these individuals are suffering from precisely the same cause of pain, viz., a temporarily crippled muscle or set of muscles which has been compelled to work against the grain. Why this state of things should invariably be interpreted as sensation in the form of acute pain never absent, but severely aggravated by every movement of the affected part, is a matter beyond our powers of explanation, we must accept it as an ultimate fact for the present.
There is scarcely any need to describe the pain of myalgia, since almost every one has suffered either from lumbago, or from a stiff neck produced by cold. The pain is essentially the same in all cases; it is an aching actually felt either in or toward the tendinous insertions of the affected muscles, and sharply renewed by every attempted contraction of those muscles. The variations in the character and severity of the pains are really entirely due to the greater or the less opportunity for physiological rest which the muscle can obtain. Thus the most obstinate and the most severe, kind of myalgic pain is undoubtedly that of pleurodynia – pain in the intercostal muscles and their fibrous aponeuroses – a fact which depends on the incessant movements which these muscles are compelled to perform in the act of respiration. And next to this in severity and obstinacy are myalgias of the great muscles which are incessantly engaged in maintaining, by their accurately opposed contraction, the erect position of the spinal column and of the head. This rate of proportional frequency and severity, however, must be taken as strictly relative; i. e., it is correct upon the supposition that the different sets of muscles were equally worked and that the state of nutrition was equal in the different parents. It is otherwise when the conditions are reversed. Thus, the unfortunate cobbler or tailor, who sits for long hours in one cramped and bent posture, is continuously exerting his recti abdominales (probably suffering from an under-nutrition common to all his tissues) to a degree perfectly abnormal, and out of all proportion to the functional work he is getting out of any other part of his muscular system. The consequence is, that he comes to us complaining of acute epigastric, and sometimes pubic, pain, rising to agony when he assumes his ordinary sitting posture, and only reduced to any thing moderate by the most complete extension of the whole trunk in the supine posture.
There is no need to dilate at greater length upon the varieties in the symptoms of myalgia, according as it affects one or another part of the body. We must consider, briefly the different kinds of cause that produce it. The immediate source of the pain being, as we have seen, the sense of embarrassment in a muscle obliged to contract when unfit for the work, we have to ask what are the remoter causes that can produce this special unfitness for the work of contraction. They are three: (a) Overlabor pure and simple (i. e., in proportion to the existing bulk and quality of the muscle); (b) cold, and especially damp cold, producing a semi-paralyzing effect on the vaso-motor nerves, and causing congestion and sometimes a little effusion among the fibres or within the sheath of the muscle; (c) fatty degeneration of muscle which is exposed to inevitable and incessant work. Either of these conditions may so disable the muscle that its unavoidable contractions will set up the myalgic state.
Undoubtedly however there is something further, in the shape of a natural predisposition not yet understood, which makes some patients so much more liable to suffer myalgic pain as a consequence of this sort of influences than other persons are. I am in no condition to decide what the nature of this predisposition is; I feel sure it is heightened by an inherited or acquired gouty taint, but I have seen it in people whom there is no reason to suspect of gouty tendencies. It appears to have no connection with true rheumatism.
Still after all that can be said, myalgia remains a disease chiefly of local origin, and depending for nine-tenths of its causation upon a derangement between the balance of work and nutrition in the muscle.
As regards the diagnosis of myalgia from neuralgia, which is a very important matter, the following are the main points that we should recollect:

The treatment of myalgia is not only satisfactory in itself, but often affords, in its results, a very desirable confirmation of diagnosis.
For a very large number of cases, all that is required is (a) to put and keep the affected muscle in a position of full extension, which is only to be changed at somewhat rare intervals; (b) to cover the skin all over and round it with spongio-piline, so as to maintain a perpetual vapor-bath; (c) on the subsidence of the acutest pain and tenderness, to complete the treatment by one or two Turkish baths, to be taken in the manner that I have recommended by speaking of the prophylaxis of neuralgia.
When treatment such as this cures a pain which was greatly aggravated by muscular movement, we may be sure that pain was myalgic and not neuralgic.
The pain, however, is not unfrequently rebellious to such simple remedies as these, more especially when (as in pleurodynia) we are not able to enforce complete physiological rest of the part. When this is the case, we shall find the internal use of twenty and thirty grain doses of muriate of ammonia by far the most effective remedy. In the first very acute stage of a severe case it may be advisable to inject morphia hypodermically; but this is seldom necessary. The muriate-of-ammonia treatment may be usefully accompanied by prolonged gentle frictions, three or four times a day, with a weak chloroform liniment.
When there is visibly a very great deficiency in the general nutrition, we shall often fail to obtain a cure until we have remedied this defect; and accordingly, in the majority of cases of half-starved and overworked needle-women, cobblers, tailors, and the like, who present themselves in the out-patient room, I accompany the above-named treatment with the steady administration of cod-liver oil for three or four weeks or more.
There is one remedy for this pain which I have myself seen used in only a few cases, but which I believe promises exceedingly well for the treatment of obstinate myalgia; viz., acupuncture. I have not even mentioned it as a remedy for neuralgia, for I believe it to be totally useless in true cases of that disease, whether applied in the simple form or in that of galvano-puncture. I think very differently of its use in myalgia; and I venture to believe that it is entirely to cases of this disease that the exceedingly interesting observations of Mr. T. P. Teale, in a recent number of the Lancet, apply. Where (after the usual remedies for myalgia have been applied) we are unable to get rid of a deep-seated and fixed muscular pain, I believe it to be excellent practice to plunge two or three long needles deeply into the muscle near its tendinous attachment.
CHAPTER II.
SPINAL IRRITATION
I retain this phrase, not because it is an absolutely good one, but because it has become so familiar that it is difficult to dispense with it. We have taken a useful step, however, in separating the true neuralgias from the somewhat indefinite group of diseases to which this title has been given. I think the reader who has carefully studied Part I. of this work will not deny that the latter disorders present a very clear and definite common outline which distinguishes them essentially from the vaguer affections to be described under the present heading.
Spinal irritation, in my sense, includes all those conditions in which, without any special mental affection, and without any single nerve being definitely affected, there are sensations varying between mere cutaneous tenderness, often of a large and irregular surface, and acute pain approaching neuralgia in character, together with fixed tenderness of certain vertebræ on deep pressure. A very large majority of the phenomena are such as would be popularly included (now that they are known not to be of an inflammatory character) under the term "hysterical." That unhappy word crosses our path at every turn in a most embarrassing manner, and yet it can hardly at present be said that we could afford to do without it.
The more typical cases of so-called "hysterical hyperæsthesia" present the following phenomena: Along with the general symptoms of the hysterical temperament (tendency to causeless depression, variable spirits, sensation of globus, semi-convulsive attacks terminated by the discharge of a great quantity of pale, limpid urine) there is commonly a marked superficial tenderness of the surface everywhere, and an exaggeration of reflex irritability. The general tenderness is so far merely cutaneous that deep pressure is ordinarily borne better than the lightest finger-touch. But besides this there are usually one or several spots in which the tenderness is more profound and genuine. There is almost sure to be some point in the spinal column where firm pressure not merely evokes a complaint of pain, but also induces secondary objective phenomena connected with distant organs, such as nausea and vomiting when the cervical vertebræ are tender, severe gastric pain when the dorsal vertebræ are tender, etc. In such cases there is not only spinal tenderness, but very usually also a well-marked tenderness in the epigastrium and the left hypochondrium, the trepied hysterique of Briquet. The reader must, however, be warned that the whole of these three tender points may be merely myalgic, and it is necessary very carefully to observe whether local movements do or do not seriously aggravate the pain in them. And, on the other hand, the spinal tender point may be merely the "point apophysaire" of a true neuralgia which exhibits no other symptoms of the so-called hysteric constitution.
The kind of hysteria that is joined with the existence of fixed tender spots in definite points of the vertebral column is not commonly distinguished by the occurrence of cutaneous anæsthesia; but those writers are certainly wrong in saying that such a combination never takes place. I have seen examples of the most marked union of the two classes of symptoms in the same person.
These cases of so-called spinal irritation with general hysteric manifestations are very commonly attended with paroxysmal pains that approach true neuralgia in character. Nor is it to be denied that we sometimes meet with the combination of general hysteria, spinal tenderness in definite points (with secondary spasmodic or paralytic phenomena always following pressure exerted on the latter), and true neuralgia limited to one nerve. But the more typical spinal irritation cases are merely complicated with a tendency to vague pains which are shifting both in character and position, not with definite unilateral neuralgia always haunting the same nerve and exhibiting more or less of the same type. In fact, as far as one can judge in the absence of any precise information as to the condition of the nervous centres in such cases, it would seem likely that the ordinary cases of spinal irritation differ from the true neuralgias chiefly in this – that the injury, or inherited weakness of organization, or both, which is at the root of the malady, is at once slighter in degree, and spread over a larger tract of the nervous centres, than that which produces a true neuralgia. I believe that Dr. Radcliffe is right in supposing it to be probable that a blow or other injury to the back producing general spinal shock, is the original but unsuspected cause of a large proportion of these cases. One of the most perfect examples of spinal irritation that I have ever seen (and which also contrasts keenly with the commoner hysteric affections on the one hand, and the true neuralgiæ on the other) was that of a girl whom I examined together with Dr. Walshe, Dr. Reynolds, and Dr. Bridge. This young lady was a most intelligent person, and not in the slightest degree inclined to the apathy and idleness so often seen in hysterical people. She had received what was thought at the time to be a very slight contusion in a railway collision, in which, however, her sister, who was in the same carriage, had been severely injured. She nursed this sister assiduously, and it was not till three or four months later that her own health began to fail seriously; but she then became anæmic and extremely depressed. About six months after the accident it was quite casually discovered that there was a spot over the lowest cervical vertebra, pressure on which gave her exquisite pain and a sensation of extreme nausea; and the very curious observation was made that such pressure instantaneously produced extinction of the right pulse, the left pulse remaining unaltered. In this case it cannot be doubted that a serious shock had been communicated to a lateral segment of the cord involving chiefly the vaso-motor nerve fibres, in which probably some decided material lesion had been gradually set up; and besides this there was probably slighter damage to the spinal cord generally, as there was great general feebleness of movement, though no actual paralysis of the limbs.
Along with the phenomena of fixed spinal tenderness, without distinct neuralgia of any particular nerve, we not unfrequently observe the development of more or less decided tenderness of some of the internal surfaces of the body. I have recently had under my care a young woman in whom a very tender point was developed over the second cervical vertebra, and who suffered from such persistent tenderness of the whole posterior part of the pharynx, that I was for some time seriously apprehensive of the existence of spinal caries and post-pharyngeal abscess. The general character of her symptoms, however, induced me to hope that the case was one of spinal irritation merely, and the event proved that this was the case, for under the use of iron and small doses of strychnia she recovered completely in about three weeks. In another patient who came under my care about twelve months ago, there was extraordinary sensitiveness of the gastric mucous membrane, causing exquisite pain after she had eaten almost any thing: there was only occasional vomiting, however, and there had never been any hæmorrhage, so that the evidence for gastric ulcer, which I otherwise inclined to think existed, was insufficient. I discovered that pressure on the third or the fourth dorsal vertebra gave great pain, and produced a strong inclination to vomit; this made it probable that the affection was spinal, and accordingly all treatment addressed to the stomach was abandoned. Flying blisters to the neighborhood of the painful spinal points quickly relieved all the symptoms.
Another distressing class of symptoms, which is very commonly observed in connection with these cases of spinal irritation, is that of abnormal arterial pulsations: I am not sure whether even severe neuralgia produces more distress than does this pulsation. I have repeatedly seen abnormal pulsation of the carotids in connection with fixed tender-points over the cervical or the upper dorsal vertebræ; and still more commonly pulsation of the abdominal aorta in connection with tenderness over one or two of the upper dorsal vertebræ. Spasmodic cough and spasmodic dyspnœa frequently accompany tenderness of points in the upper half of the spinal column; and in one instance I have seen pressure on the lowest cervical vertebræ produce a paroxysm which looked alarmingly like angina pectoris. A case of singularly prolonged and obstinate spasmodic hiccough which came under my notice was distinguished by the presence of a fixed tender spot over the third dorsal vertebra.
Prolonged spastic contraction of voluntary muscles, going on, sometimes for weeks, and even months, is a phenomenon that has often been observed; it may attack the arm only, or may affect all the limbs, and the muscles of the trunk and of the neck: it is for the most part symmetrical, but is occasionally unilateral. It begins in the extremities, and is very commonly limited to them; it is much more gentle than tetanic spasm, and is also painless, or nearly so; but the contraction is often strong enough to resist very vigorous efforts at artificial extension.
Paralyses, both of bowel and bladder, have been recorded among the occasional phenomena of spinal irritation with fixed tender points; but I cannot say that I have ever seen such an occurrence. On the whole, I must say that by far the most frequent phenomena of spinal irritation that I have seen have been somewhat diffuse cutaneous or mucous tenderness and irritability (without acute pain) and the presence of tormenting arterial throbbings; also a marked tendency to aggravation of some symptoms, especially the gastric, when firm pressure is made upon the tender spinal points. For a further and fuller account of the phenomena of spinal irritation I may refer the reader to the able article of Dr. Radcliffe,48 and the work of the brothers Griffin, already quoted; adding the suggestion, however, that both these authorities, and especially the Griffins, appear to me not to draw a sufficiently clear distinction between the class of cases that I have been attempting to describe and the true neuralgias.
After what has been said, there is no need to draw out a formal list of the points of diagnosis between spinal irritation and neuralgia. It must be admitted, moreover, that the two forms of diseases have a strong connection in the fact that they are each of them most frequently developed in the descendants of neurotic families. It is by the more generalized character of the symptoms, and the absence of the tendency to perpetual recurrence of paroxysmal pain in one definite nerve, that spinal irritation is mainly distinguishable from true neuralgia. I may add that there is a marked distinction, also, in the results of treatment.
The treatment of spinal irritation is, it must be confessed still in an unsatisfactory position; and I believe that a good deal of unnecessary discouragement has been occasioned to physicians by their failures to cure supposed neuralgias which really belonged to the spinal irritation class. I would assuredly by no means assert that genuine neuralgia is not frequently intractable, or even incurable; but it is certainly much more curable than spinal irritation; and for this reason, mainly as I believe – that there is much more possibility of aiming our remedies at the actual seat of the disease. On the other hand, in spinal irritation we are confused and distracted with a variety of phenomena for which even the most subtle analysis will frequently fail to trace a common origin. It is true that the existence of definite tender spots in the spine apparently suggests a strictly local application of remedies; and it true also that medication based upon this fact is sometimes very effective; but this is, in my experience, only an occasional result, and the practitioner who trusts to local measures will frequently be disappointed. And, on the other hand, the general tonic treatment, and the use of special medicines, like quinine and arsenic, or the hypodermic injection of morphia oratropia, have nothing like the extensive utility in the treatment of spinal irritation that they possess in that of true neuralgia. Of internal remedies, by far the most useful in my hands have been sesquichloride of iron with small doses of strychnia, and the milder vegetable bitters, especially calumba.
There is one special phase, however, of spinal irritation which is very amenable to the direct, treatment, viz., cutaneous and mucous tenderness. Whatever the "hyperæsthetic" part is within reach, so that we can apply Faradization, we can almost certainly eradicate the morbid sensibility very quickly. The secondary current of an electro-magnetic or volta-electric induction apparatus is to be employed; the conductors should be of dry metal and the negative one, which is to be applied to the painful surface, should be in the form of the wire brush. The positive pole is to be placed on some indifferent spot, and the negative is to be stroked briskly backward and forward over the sensitive skin, a pretty strong current being employed. The process is painful so much so that it will often be advisable, with delicate patients, either to administer chloroform or to inject morphia subcutaneously before the Faradization. A very few daily sittings of four or five minutes length will generally remove the morbid tenderness completely. Where the tender part is within one of the cavities, at the rectum, bladder, vagina, or pharynx, we must of course use a solid negative conductor of appropriate form, and must content ourselves with applying it steadily to one point after another of the sensitive surface.
The fact that Faradization proves so remarkably useful, in these cases of spinal irritation with diffuse cutaneous or mucous tenderness, is in itself a strong diagnostic between this sort of affection and the true neuralgiæ, which, as I have stated are seldom benefited, and are often made worse, by the interrupted current, though the constant current frequently mitigates or cures them.
Sometimes where it is not possible to apply the remedy directly to the sensitive surface, we may nevertheless do great good by sending the interrupted current through it. Thus, in gastric sensitiveness connected with spinal tenderness in the upper dorsal region, I have seen very great relief afforded by sending a current from the positive pole, placed on the tender vertebræ, to a broad, negative conductor placed on the epigastrium. And similarly, I have seen an acutely sensitive condition of the neck of the bladder greatly soothed by the passage of a current from a painful lumbar vertebra to the perinæum immediately behind the scrotum.
Undoubtedly, however, the more serious cases of spinal irritation will yield only (if they yield at all) to a prolonged treatment in which very skilful use is made of general hygienic measures, and especially of morbal influences. As the brothers Griffin long ago pointed out, although rest is useful in the early stages of this malady, if the disease does not quickly yield to this and to appropriate tonic medication, and perhaps local applications to the spine, it will not do to keep the patient recumbent and confined to the house; on the contrary at whatever cost of immediate discomfort, he (or she for these patients are by far the most frequently females) must be roused up, and persuaded or compelled to take out-door exercise, and if possible to travel, and divert the mind by complete change of scene. When such expensive remedies are out of the question, it seems better that patients, even seemingly very feeble, should take to their ordinary avocations in life again, and fight down the tendency to invalidism. But of course, the decision on such a point must rest with the tact and judgment of the practitioner in each individual case, for there are, doubtless, instances in which the attempt to carry out such a plan, even moderately, would break down the remaining strength, and make matters worse than they were before.
In the worse case of spinal irritation that I ever saw, that of a young lady, aged twenty-eight, there were pronounced anæmia and general feebleness, the true hysteric trepied of tender points, painful irritability of the stomach, which baffled all medical advisers and resisted almost every possible form of tonic and nervine medicines, counter-irritation to the spine, and, in fact every thing that one dared attempt with so feeble-looking a patient, but at once cleared up and was quite cured after marriage. And there can be no question that a very large proportion of these cases in single women (who form by far the greater number of subjects of spinal irritation) are due to this conscious or unconscious irritation kept up by an unsatisfied sexual want. In some patients there cannot be a doubt that this condition of things is indefinitely aggravated by the practice of self abuse; but it would be most unjust to think that this is a necessary element in the causation; on the contrary, it is certain that very many young persons (women more especially) are tormented by the irritability of the sexual organs without having the least consciousness of sensual desire, and present the sad spectacle of a vie manquee without ever knowing the true source of the misery which incapacitates them for all the active duties of life. It is a singular fact, that in occasional instances one may even see two sisters inheriting the same kind of nervous organization, both tormented with the symptoms of spinal irritation, and both probably suffering from repressed sexual function, but of whom one shall be pure-minded and entirely unconscious of the real source of her troubles, while the other is a victim to conscious and fruitless sexual irritation.
I have already causally alluded to the danger of mistaking mere myalgia for spinal irritation and must again enforce this consideration upon the reader. Myalgic tender points in the region of the spine are common enough; and it would be easy without careful attention, to mistake them for the deeper-seated vertebral tenderness which is truly characteristic of spinal irritation. Hence the utmost care must be taken to ascertain the true history of the commencement of the disorder whether it succeeded to great and long continued fatigue of particular sets of muscles, and whether it is specially aggravated by contractions of those muscles, and relieved by their full extension. The differences of treatment which depend on the diagnosis are too obvious to need dwelling upon.
The question of administering remedies with the direct intention of procuring sleep, for patients suffering from spinal irritation, often becomes an important and a very difficult one. It is, for the most part, highly objectionable to commence the use of such remedies; and yet sleeplessness is a very distressing symptom with many patients, and is, of course in itself exhausting and deleterious. For as long as we possibly can, we should content ourselves with efforts to produce sleep by the timely administration of nourishment. The same general rule of a very generous (though not very stimulating) diet to be enforced as carefully as in the case of sufferers from neuralgia. But it is especially advisable in spinal irritation; that the patient should take some food shortly before bedtime; and it is well, also to place food within reach at the bedside, so that if he wakes up he may take some. If, however, we are absolutely driven to employ hypnotics, we must commence with the very mildest. The popular remedy of a pillow stuffed with hops will sometimes suffice; and a better way of administering the volatile principle of hops is to scatter a few hops on hot water in an inhaler, and let the patient breathe the steam. Hot foot-baths, with mustard, are also very useful. If these fail, chloral, in moderate doses is probably the best and safest remedy, and, with care not to give too much, we may go on using the same dose without increase for a good many times.
CHAPTER III.
THE PAINS OF HYPOCHONDRIASIS
There is perhaps nothing, in the whole range of practical medicine, more difficult to seize with clear comprehension, and picture to the mind with accuracy, than the group of pseudo-neuralgiæ which belong to the domain of hypochondriasis. They are among the most indefinable, and at the same time the most intractable, of nervous affections.
To understand what hypochondriac pains are, we must first be familiar with the general character of the hypochondriacal temperament, for the pains are only a subordinate and ever-varying phenomena of the general disease.
Hypochondriasis is not insanity, if by insanity we mean intellectual perversion dependent mainly or entirely on the state of the higher nervous centres. But it is closely allied to insanity in its phenomena, only that these are, as it were, manifested in a scattered form, unequally distributed over the whole central nervous system, and especially affecting the spinal sensory centres. And its radical relationship to true insanity is strongly indicated by the fact that the sufferers from hypochondriasis are nearly, if not quite, always members of families in which distinct insanity has shown itself; indeed, more often than not, of families which have been strongly tainted in this way. In the majority of instances there are psychical peculiarities of a marked kind which accompany or precede the development of the abnormal sensations which form the especial torment of hypochondriacs. Without apparent cause, they begin to evince a heightened self-feeling and an anxious concentration of their thoughts upon the state of one or more of their bodily organs. Or it may be that, before any such definite bias is given to their thoughts, they simply become less sociable and more self-centred, and are subject to fits of indefinite and inexplicable depression, or at least to great variability of spirits. But before long they begin to experience definite morbid sensations, most commonly connected with the digestive organs, and very often accompanied by positive derangement of digestion of an objective character; such as flatulence, sour eructation, spasmodic stomach-pain, etc. Along with these phenomena, or soon afterward (and not unfrequently before the patient has acquired that intensity of morbid conviction of his having some special disease which is afterward so marked a peculiarity of his mental state), he very often becomes the subject of the kind of pains which it is the special purpose of this chapter to describe.
The pains of hypochondriasis, when they assume any more definite form than that of mere dyspeptic uneasiness, present many analogies with neuralgia. They are not, usually, periodic in any regular manner, but they have the same tendency to complete intermission, and they frequently haunt some one or more definite nerves for a considerable period of time. Of all nerves that are liable to this kind of affections the vagus is undoubtedly the most susceptible; hypochondriac patients very frequently complain of pseudo-anginoid and pseudo-gastralgic pains; next in frequency are nervous pain in the region of the liver, or in the rectum or bladder. The main distinctions by which they are separable from true neuralgia are two: in the first place, the character of the pain nearly always is more of the boring or burning kind than of the acutely darting sort which is most usual in true neuralgia; and, secondly, the influence of mental attention in aggravating the pain is far more pronounced than in the latter malady; indeed, it is often possible, by merely engaging the patient in conversation on other topics, to cause the pain to disappear altogether for the time. But in hypochondriasis it is not often that we are left, for any long time, to these means of diagnosis only; the special character of the disease is that the morbid sensations shift from one place to another, in a manner that is quite unlike that of the true neuralgias. The patient who to-day complains of the most severe gastralgia, or liver-pain, will to-morrow place all his sufferings in the cardiac region, or in the rectum, or will complain of a deep fixed pain within his head; and these changes are often most rapid and frequent. Frequently there are also peculiar skin sensations, which usually approach formication in type, and these, like the pains, are apt to shift with rapidity from one part of the body to another. Later on in the disease, especially in those worst cases which approach most closely to the type of true insanity, there are often hallucinations of a peculiar and characteristic nature, such as the conviction of the patient that he has some animal inside him gnawing his vitals, that he is made of glass and in constant danger of being broken, and a variety of similar absurdities. In short, it is not the fully-developed cases of hypochondriasis that need puzzle us, these are usually distinct enough; but the earlier and less characteristic stages in which pain may be nearly the only symptom that is particularly prominent.
In hypochondriasis, as in hysteria, there is often great sensitiveness of the surface; and, as in hysteria, this sensitiveness is found to be very superficial, so that a light touch often hurts more than firm, deep pressure. As in hysteria, too, the tenderness is a phenomenon so greatly affected by the mind, that, if we can divert the patient's attention for a moment, he will let us touch him anywhere, without noticing it at all.
It is a marked peculiarity of hypochondriasis that it is far more common in men than in women; a relation which is precisely the opposite to that which rules in neuralgia. Hypochondriasis is also pre-eminently a disease of adult middle life; it is scarcely ever seen in youth, except as the result of excessive masturbation acting on a temperament hereditarily predisposed to insanity.
The results of treatment frequently assist our diagnosis in difficult cases. Almost any medicine will relieve the pains of the hypochondriac for a time, and it is generally far easier to do him good, temporarily, than it is to relieve a neuralgic patient; but, en revanche, every remedy is apt to lose its affect after a little while. The only chance of producing permanent benefit in hypochondriasis is by the judicious combination of remedies that remove symptoms (especially dyspepsia, flatulence, etc.), which mischievously engage the patient's mind, with general tonics, and, above all, which such alterations in the patient's habits of daily life as take him out of himself and compel him to interest himself in the affairs of the world around him. And, after all, our best efforts will frequently lead to nothing but disappointment.
It is notoriously the fact that hypochondriasis especially affects the rich and idle classes; but it would be a great mistake to suppose that it never attacks the poor or the hard-worked: only, in the latter instances, it apparently needs, for it development, the existence of strong family tendencies to neurotic disease, and especially to insanity. Among the numerous debilitated persons who attend the out-patient rooms of our hospitals we every now and then encounter as typical a case of hypochondriasis as could be found even among the rich and gloomy old bachelors who haunt some of our London clubs. I have one such patient under my care now, who has been a repeated visitor at the Westminster Hospital during many years: he has had pseudo-neuralgic pains nearly everywhere at different times; but his most complaint has been of pain in the groin and scrotum of the right side. The existence of what seemed, at first, like the tender points of lumbo-abdominal neuralgia, at one time led me to believe it was a case of that affection; but I was soon undeceived by finding that the tenderness did not remain constant to the same points, but shifted about. This man has professed, by turns, to derive benefit from nearly all the drugs in the Pharmacopœia; but the only remedies that have done him good, for more than a day or two at a time, have been valerian and assafœtida, with the prolonged use of cod-liver oil. He will never be really cured; and I suspect that the secret of his maladies is an inveterate habit of masturbation acting on a nervous system hereditarily predisposed to hypochondriasis.
Sometimes it happens that the starting-point of hypochondriac pains, simulating neuralgia, is a blow, or other bodily injury acting on a predisposed nervous system. Another of my patients at the Westminster Hospital was a policeman, who had received a severe kick in the groin; he suffered pains which at first seemed to wear all the characters of true neuralgia in the pudic nerve, but afterward shifted to other places and exhibited all the intractability of hypochondriasis; the patient also developed the regular appearance and the characteristic hallucinations of the latter disease. On the last occasion when I saw him, he struck me as likely to become really insane, in the melancholic form; and the probability is that the casualty which he suffered was only accidentally the starting-point of a malady which was inherent in him since birth, and would have been developed, in any case, at some period of his life.
CHAPTER IV.
THE PAINS OF LOCOMOTOR ATAXY
Considering the vast amount that has been written about this disease during the last few years, it might be thought superfluous for me to give any description of its general features. But it unfortunately happens that there is still great divergence of opinion among authorities as to the true limitation of the group of cases that can properly be ranked under this title, and, indeed, as to the propriety of employing the title at all. The phrase ataxie locomotrice progressive, as every one knows, was applied by Duchenne de Boulogne to a class of cases which really only form a subdivision of the group known under the older title of tabes dorsalis and the most advanced German pathologists maintain that the old word was better, and that Duchenne was altogether wrong in making the one symptom, ataxy of locomotion, the bases of a new phraseology;49 more especially as his theory as to the seat of the morbid changes was undoubtedly erroneous.
In this country, however, there is as yet no disposition to give up the phrase locomotor ataxy, and it only remains to define with sufficient care the class of cases to which the word is here meant to apply. The disease is understood to depend upon a degeneration of the spinal cord, of which the following description is given by Lockhart Clarke:50 "In true locomotor ataxy, the spinal cord is invariably altered in structure. Its membranes, however, are sometimes apparently unaffected, or affected only in a slight degree; but generally they are much congested, and I have seen them thickened posteriorly by exudations, and adherent, not only to each other, but to the posterior surface of the cord. The posterior columns, including the posterior nerve-roots, are the parts of the cord which are chiefly altered in structure. This alteration is peculiar, and consists of atrophy and degeneration of the nerve fibres to a greater or less extent, with hypertrophy of the connective tissue, which give to the columns a grayish and more transparent aspect; in this tissue are embedded a multitude of corpora amylacea. Many of the blood vessels that travel the columns are loaded or surrounded to a variable depth by oil-globules of various sizes. For the production of ataxy, it seems to be necessary that the changes extend along a certain length, from one to two inches of the cord. The posterior nerve-roots, both within and without the cord, are frequently affected by the same kind of degeneration, which sometimes extends to the surface even of the lateral columns, and occasionally along the edges of the anterior. Not unfrequently the extremity of the posterior cornua, and even deeper parts of the gray substance, are more or less damaged by areas of disintegration. The morbid process appears to travel from centre to periphery, that is, from the spinal cord to the posterior roots. In the cerebral nerves, on the contrary, the morbid change seems to travel in the opposite direction, that is, from the periphery toward the centres. From the optic nerves it has been found to extend as far as the corpora geniculata, but seldom as far as the corpora quadrigemina. With the exception of the fifth, seventh, and eighth pair, all the cerebral nerves have occasionally been found more or less altered in structure."
The symptoms which occur in cases in which the above are the morbid appearances found after death are (roughly speaking) as follows:51 "A peculiar gait, arising from want of co-ordinating power in the lower extremities, a gait precipitate and staggering, the legs starting hither and thither in a very disorderly manner, and the heels coming down with a stamp at each step."
No true paralysis in the lower extremities or elsewhere. Characteristic neuralgic pains, erratic paroxysmal in the feet and legs chiefly – pains of a boring, throbbing, shooting character, like those caused by a sharp electric shock.
More or less numbness, in the feet and legs chiefly, in all forms of sensibility, excepting that by which differences of temperature are recognized.
Frequent impairment of sight or hearing, one or both.
Frequent transitory or permanent strabismus or ptosis, one or both.
No very obvious paralysis of the bladder or lower bowel.
No necessary impairment of sexual power.
No tingling or kindred phenomenon.
No marked tremulous, convulsive, or spasmodic phenomena.
No marked impairment of muscular nutrition and irritability.
No impairment of the mental faculties.
Occasional injection of the conjunctivæ, with contraction of the pupils.
The probable limitation of the distinctive phenomenon of locomotor ataxy (the want of co-ordinating motor power) to the lower extremities.
The above description includes all the necessary facts for the recognition of the disease, except one, namely, that the use of the eyesight is always needed in order to prevent the patient from falling during progression; and is usually necessary even to enable him to stand upright without falling.
The pains of locomotor ataxy are early phenomena in most cases, and they are usually present, more or less, throughout the course of the disease.
They are often preceded by strabismus, with or without ptosis; the strabismus, is usually accompanied by amblyopia. It may happen, however, that neuralgic pains are, for a considerable time, the only noticeable phenomena; or they may be attended with a certain amount of anæsthesia.
The most frequent type of the pains is lancinating or stabbing; they are like violent neuralgias occurring successively in various nerves; shifting about from one to another. Sometimes it will happen that the pain remains fixed to one particular nerve for hours together; but it never continues long without showing the characteristic tendency to move about. Most commonly our diagnosis is soon assisted by the occurrence of a greater or less degree of ataxy. But, even before the setting in of definite atactic symptoms, the shifting character of the pains, and the development of a very noticeable amount of anæsthesia, together with the absence of anything like positive motor paralysis, will have given us the necessary clew.
The effect of treatment, or rather its want of effect, usually affords powerful assistance in distinguishing the pains of locomotor ataxy from those of true neuralgia. Even where the pain has been fixed for some hours in a single nerve, and has been stopped by some powerful remedy (such as hypodermic morphia), it will be apt speedily to recur, and frequently in some quite distant nerve.
Locomotor ataxy is a disease affecting chiefly the male sex, and occurring in the immense majority of cases between the thirty-fifth and the fiftieth year.
Not merely is it strictly limited to individuals who belong to families with neurotic tendencies, but it is itself frequently seen to occur in several members of the same family, and sometimes of the same generation. When, therefore, we meet with neuralgic pains of the shifting type above described, it is very important at once to make careful inquiries whether any members of the family have suffered from symptoms of ataxy going on to a fatal result. Otherwise, we might be the more readily deceived into the idea that the pains were merely neuralgic, because the symptoms of the disease are not unfrequently provoked by such causes as fatigue and exposure to cold or wet, which are also very ordinary exciting causes of true neuralgia.
CHAPTER V.
THE PAINS OF CEREBRAL ABSCESS
Cerebral abscesses is, fortunately, a rare disease; but the very fact of its rarity makes the resemblance of the pain it causes to that of neuralgia the more likely to lead us into serious errors. We are apt to forget the possibility of suppuration of the brain on account of its infrequence.
Pain in the head is present as an early symptom of abscess in the brain in a large proportion of cases in which there is pain at all. [Of seventy-five cases of cerebral abscess analyzed by Gull and Sutton (Reynolds's "System of Medicine," vol. ii.), pain was a symptom in thirty-nine, and most frequently an early symptom.] Many cases are recorded in which it preceded every other morbid sign by a considerable period. It is usually more or less paroxysmal, often strikingly so; in the latter case, it bears a great similarity to neuralgia. On the other hand, it sometimes takes the shape of a fixed burning sensation, much less resembling neuralgia. The situation of the pain by no means always, nor even usually, corresponds to the situation of the cerebral abscess; on the contrary, abscess in the cerebellum has often caused pain referred to the anterior part of the head, and so on. So long as the disease remains characterized only by pain, more or less, of a paroxysmal character, the diagnosis must be very uncertain; but in the great majority of cases certain more distinctive symptoms soon become superadded; either convulsions (sometimes hemiplegic), vertigo, coma, paralysis, vomiting, or a combination of some of these.
In the stage in which there is as yet no conspicuous symptom but severe pain, the diagnosis of cerebral abscess from neuralgia must rest on the following points of contrast:

The only case of cerebral abscess that I have personally seen, in which the above points of distinction would have been insufficient, was that of a boy of sixteen, in whom the only discoverable symptom, for nearly three months, was pain, very strongly resembling ordinary migraine, recurring not oftener than once in ten days or a fortnight, lasting for some hours at a time, and nearly always ending in vomiting, and disappearing after sleep. At the end of the three months, acute pain in the left ear set in, and this was followed, soon, by right hemiplegia, coma, and death. It was then discovered, although it had formerly been denied, that the boy had suffered from discharge from the left ear, following a febrile attack which had been marked by sore-throat, and followed by desquamation of the cuticle – evidently scarlet fever. In all cases of severe pain in the head, it is a golden rule to inquire most carefully as to the possible existence, present or past, of discharge from the ear, or other signs of caries of the temporal bone; and, even if no positive history of this kind be given, we should still regard with great suspicion any case in which there has been scarlet fever followed by deafness.
CHAPTER VI.
PAINS OF ALCOHOLISM
A very important class of pains, which are occasionally confounded with true neuralgias, are those which occur in certain forms of chronic alcoholism. The diagnosis of their true nature is a matter of the utmost consequence, and the failure to recognize them for what they are may have very disastrous results. It is a curious fact that this consequence of chronic alcoholic poisoning has been entirely overlooked by some of the best known writers on that affection; it has, however, been described by Mr. John Higginbottom, and also by M. Leudet.
It must be clearly understood that the pains of which we are now to speak are not among the common consequences of chronic excess in drink. The affections of sensation which most usually occur in alcoholism take the shape either of anæsthesia, or of this combined with anomalous feelings partaking more or less of the character of formication. Chronic drinking has also a tendency, in its later stages, when the nutrition of the nervous centres has been considerably impaired by the habit, to set up true neuralgia, of a formidable type, in subjects who are hereditarily predisposed to neuroses. But the affection of which I now speak may occur at any stage except the very earliest, and, though often severely painful, is essentially different both in its seat and in its general characters, from neuralgia proper.
The earliest symptoms from which the patient usually suffers in these cases are insomnia, and intense depression of spirits, which, however, is not incompatible, indeed is frequently combined, with a morbid activity and restlessness of thought. There is generally marked loss of appetite, but often there is none of the morning nausea so characteristic of the common forms of alcoholism. Nor is there, ordinarily, any special unsteadiness of the muscular system. The pains are usually first felt in the shoulder and down the spine; but as the case progresses they especially attack the wrist and ankles; and it is in these latter situations that I have found them to be most decidedly complained of. Their similarity to neuralgia consists (a) in their somewhat paroxysmal character; (b) in their frequently recurring at about the same hour of the day, most commonly toward night; and (c) in their special aggravation by bodily and mental fatigue.
Their differences from neuralgia are – (a) that they never follow the course of a recognizable single nerve; (b) that they are nearly always present in more than one limb, and usually in both halves of the body, at the same time; and (c) especially, that they are far less promptly and effectually relieved by hypodermic morphia than are the true neuralgias; indeed, opiates very frequently only slightly alleviate the pain, while they excite and agitate the patient and render sleep impossible. On the contrary, a large dose of wine or brandy will never fail to procure temporary comfort and induce sleep, at least until the patient reaches an advanced stage of the disorder, and is, in fact, on the verge of delirium tremens.
I am not quite sure that I am right in believing that there is a special physiognomy for this form of chronic alcoholism, and yet I am much inclined to believe that there is. All the patients whom I have seen suffering with it have presented a peculiar brown sallowness of face, and a general harsh dryness of the skin, which has usually lost its natural clearness, not only in the face, but even more remarkably in the hands, which are so dark-colored as to appear as if they were dirty. There is usually considerable leanness of the limbs, and, though the abdomen may be somewhat prominent, this does not seem to depend much on the presence of fat, but rather on relaxation of the abdominal muscles, and sometimes flatulent distention of the stomach and intestines. The hands are usually hot, sometimes quite startlingly so.
Some of the patients suffer, besides the pains in the limbs (which they often describe as resembling the feeling of a tight band pressing severely around the ankles or wrists), from frequent or occasional attacks of genuine hemicrania; such a combination is to me always a suspicious sign, and induces me immediately to direct my attention to the possibility of chronic alcoholic poisoning. Otherwise, the limb-pains are often spoken of as resembling rheumatism, but there is no swelling of joints, and usually no decided tenderness of the painful parts. The patient has usually a particular worn and haggard appearance, complains of intense fatigue after the most moderate muscular exertion, and is usually utterly indisposed to physical exercise even though the mind, as already said, may display a feverish activity.
So far as I have seen, the subjects of this affection are by far the most frequently women; and I am inclined to attribute this predisposition of the sex not to inherent peculiarities of female organization, but to the fact that a much larger proportion of intemperate women than of intemperate men indulge in secret excess. They never get drunk, probably, but they fly to the relief of alcohol upon every trivial occasion of bodily or mental distress; and this habit may have been going on for years before it comes to be suspected by their friends or their medical attendant. Meantime, they have been more or less looked upon, and have looked upon themselves as, "debilitated" and "neuralgic" subjects, and have come, either with or without mistaken medical advice, to consider free stimulation as the proper treatment for the very ailments which have been produced by their own unfortunate habits. I cannot avoid the expression of the misgiving, that imperfect diagnosis, and consequent erroneous prescription, have done great harm in many such cases. It has happened to me no less than three times within the last six months to be called to lady patients, all suffering from alcoholism induced by a habit of taking stimulants for the relief of so-called neuralgic pain; and in the most distressing of these the mischief had been greatly aggravated by a prescription of brandy, based on the erroneous idea that the pains were truly neuralgic. I have already protested against this kind of medication, even in cases that are truly neuralgic in character; but it is doubly mischievous where given for a state of things which actually depends on alcoholic excess.
It is undoubtedly very difficult, sometimes, to elicit the truth, even in cases where we may entertain considerable suspicion that alcoholic excesses are the real cause of the pains which the patient calls neuralgic; more especially where the patient is aware that he or she is taking an amount of alcohol which is seriously damaging to health. And it is therefore necessary to look out for every possible additional help to our diagnosis. Besides the cardinal features of the disease – the insomnia, loss of appetite, foul breath, haggard countenance, and pains encircling the limbs near the joints rather than running longitudinally down the extremities there are certain moral characteristics of the patient that often tells a significant tale. The drinker, especially if a woman, is shifty, voluble, and full of plausible theories to account for this and the other phenomenon. It will be well to try the effects of a somewhat sudden though not uncourteous remark, to the effect that the diet should be strictly unstimulating. If this be introduced with some abruptness, in the course of a conversation not apparently leading to it, the patient's manner will not unfrequently betray the truth; while, if our suspicions are groundless, we shall also probably perceive that, in the unconscious, or frankly surprised, expression of the countenance. We may sometimes derive crowning proof of the existence of alcoholic excess by cautious questions which at least reveal the fact that the patient suffers from spectral hallucinations; this is a far commoner occurrence in chronic alcoholism than is generally supposed; it needs to be inquired for with great tact, but, when established beyond doubt, and joined to insomnia and the peculiar foul breath, is of itself sufficient to establish a positive diagnosis of alcoholic poisoning.
The results of treatment, in true neuralgia and in alcoholic pains, respectively, establish an important difference between these affections. In the former malady, for instance, the hypodermic injection of morphia always produces striking palliative, and very often curative effects. In alcoholic pains this remedy either affords only trifling relief, or more commonly aggravates the malady by increasing the general nervous excitement; and the only true treatment is at once to suspend all use of stimulants, to administer quinine, and to insist upon a copious nutrition. If any hypnotic must be employed, let it be chloral, or bromide of potassium with cannabis Indica. It will be well also to put the patient upon a somewhat lengthened course of cod-liver oil. There is one special symptom from which the chronic alcoholist often suffers acutely, namely a hypersensitiveness to cold; for this I found the use of Turkish bath two or three times a week, for three or four weeks, very useful in one case that was under my care. It will be important to insist that the patient shall take the bath only after that shorter method which I have described in speaking of the prophylaxis of true neuralgia.
A very distinct and careful statement of the distinction between pain and hyperæsthesia will be found in a prize essay "On Neuralgia" by M. C. Vanlair, Jour. de Bruxelles, tom. xl., xli., 1865.